8 Underrated Comedy TV Shows You Need to Watch Right Now

Humor has an extraordinary ability to bring people together, yet it’s rather puzzling how many exceptional comedy series from recent years remain largely unrecognized. Despite the efforts of astute comedy aficionados who are adept at discovering hidden treasures, it’s disheartening to see quality shows languishing in obscurity while they deserve mainstream acclaim and a broader audience.

While some comedies have managed to capture the attention of general viewers, the proliferation of streaming options has resulted in numerous remarkable series being overlooked. Additionally, many outstanding comedies from the U.K. and beyond, though embraced in their native countries, struggle to gain international traction. From laugh-out-loud farces featuring notable actors to witty, thought-provoking satires, the following recent comedy shows are essential additions to your watchlist.

8
Poker Face (2023 – Present)

1 Season

Created by the acclaimed Rian Johnson, known for films like Knives Out, and featuring the talented Natasha Lyonne from Orange is the New Black, the series Poker Face surprisingly hasn’t garnered more widespread acclaim. This captivating crime comedy stars Lyonne as Charlie Cale, a perceptive cocktail waitress with a unique knack for detecting lies. Modeled on the classic murder-mystery genre, Poker Face employs a case-of-the-week structure akin to a contemporary, female-led take on Columbo.

With its sharp writing, standout performances, and intricate plots, Poker Face emerges as another triumph for Johnson, who also directed some of Breaking Bad’s most memorable episodes, including the iconic “Ozymandias.”With a highly anticipated second season slated for 2025, viewers yet to experience this series should prepare to dive in and enjoy a thrilling new addition to the comedy genre.

7
Pen15 (2019 – 2021)

2 Seasons

Despite limited exposure during its release amidst the COVID-19 pandemic, Pen15 remains a standout in modern television comedy. Created by and starring Maya Erskine and Anna Konkle, this series humorously explores the trials of adolescence during the early 2000s. The creators’ decision to play versions of their 13-year-old selves amid real teenagers delivers a unique exploration of the complexities of growing up, tackling mature themes often overlooked in typical teen comedies.

Although initially jarring, viewers soon find themselves entranced by the authenticity of Erskine and Konkle’s performances. Chock-full of nostalgic moments, Pen15 adeptly navigates the cringeworthy tribulations of middle school life, merging humor with poignant observations to create a series that resonates deeply.

6
The Curse (2023)

1 Season

Stepping away from his signature parody style, Nathan Fielder collaborates with Emma Stone and Benny Safdie in the brilliantly subversive comedy series, The Curse. This series follows newlyweds Asher and Whitney as they navigate the pitfalls of their reality show, Fliplanthropy. It’s an incisive commentary on cultural appropriation, privilege, and relationships that swiftly evolves into a complex narrative.

Fielder’s role as the awkward host, Asher Siegel, hints at supernatural elements when a child curses him for taking back a $100 bill he gave her. Infused with surreal humor and a distinctive style that may not appeal to all, The Curse is a compelling watch for those who appreciate Fielder’s work or admire the dreamlike storytelling of directors like David Lynch.

5
Strange Planet (2023)

1 Season

Originally stemming from Nathan W. Pyle’s beloved webcomic, Strange Planet presents a humorous take on human behavior as interpreted by alien beings. Adapted for Apple TV+ by Pyle and Rick and Morty’s Dan Harmon, the show retains the comic’s relatable charm yet has not received the attention it rightfully deserves.

With keen observations that highlight the absurdities of daily life, Strange Planet features endearing blue beings who embody human anxieties and joys. The show skillfully captures the essence of the webcomic’s humor, making it a delightful experience for viewers yet to discover its unique allure.

4
I Hate Suzie (2020 – 2022)

2 Seasons

Former pop star Billie Piper shines in the satirical British comedy, I Hate Suzie, where she plays Suzie Pickles, an actress whose life spirals after a hacking scandal. The series adeptly explores the eight stages of trauma Suzie experiences as she grapples with the fallout from the leaked content, making it deeply relevant in today’s societal landscape.

I Hate Suzie tackles themes of cancellation and the volatility of fame with a combination of humor and tension, driven by Piper’s compelling performance. Its sequel, I Hate Suzie Too, continues this fascinating exploration, highlighting the darker side of celebrity culture while maintaining its comedic essence.

3
Big Boys (2022 – 2025)

3 Seasons

Big Boys is a heartfelt, semi-autobiographical British sitcom that chronicles a young man’s exploration of his sexual identity while navigating grief from his father’s death. Starring Dylan Llewellyn from Derry Girls, the show artfully presents Jack’s journey as he finds solace among friends, successfully blending poignant moments with an effective comedic touch.

The series showcases the beautiful friendship between Jack and Danny, who are vastly different yet unconditionally supportive of each other. By addressing themes of loss and mental health without becoming preachy, Big Boys emerges as a treasure among contemporary comedies that deserves wider recognition.

2
Wellington Paranormal (2018 – 2022)

4 Seasons

While Taika Waititi is renowned for his major films like Hunt for the Wilderpeople and Thor: Ragnarok, his comedic brilliance shines through in Wellington Paranormal. This underrated spin-off series from What We Do in the Shadows follows Officers Minogue and O’Leary as they tackle supernatural occurrences in a mockumentary format.

Co-created by Waititi, Jemaine Clement, and Paul Yates, Wellington Paranormal thrives on deadpan humor, encapsulating the spirit of New Zealand comedy. With a delightful blend of monster-of-the-week tales and laughter, this series gracefully expands the What We Do in the Shadows universe, crafting its own distinct identity over four entertaining seasons.

1
Shrinking (2023 – Present)

2 Seasons

Featuring noteworthy performances from Jason Segel and the legendary Harrison Ford, Shrinking is a standout comedy that has yet to achieve the recognition it merits. Focused on a therapist coping with grief while becoming more involved in the lives of his patients, the series artfully balances humor with heartfelt moments.

Shrinking introduces a cast of relatable characters and explores the theme of radical honesty, providing a refreshing perspective in an era dominated by cynicism in comedy. Co-created by the minds behind Scrubs and Ted Lasso, the show exemplifies the blend of lightheartedness with emotional depth, ensuring viewers eagerly await the upcoming third season.

Source & Images

© 2021 The Filibuster Blog