Why Spencer Dutton Is a Better Father Figure Than Kevin Costner in Yellowstone: Insights from 1923’s Finale

**Warning! This article contains SPOILERS for the finale of 1923 season 2, titled “A Dream and a Memory.”**

In the realm of fatherhood, Spencer Dutton (played by Brandon Sklenar) appears poised to eclipse the paternal legacy of John Dutton III (Kevin Costner) from Yellowstone. The second season finale of 1923 has already laid the groundwork for Spencer’s emerging role as a father to his son, John II, born to him and the late Alexandra (Julia Schlaepfer). Tragically, Alexandra’s passing due to complications from frostbite has left Spencer to raise John II primarily on his own. Although the show only briefly depicted Spencer’s early interactions with his son, it strongly suggests he possesses the qualities of a devoted parent.

Fatherhood in 1923: A Contrast to John Dutton III

Even in the absence of a third season for 1923, Spencer’s character holds promise for future appearances in the Yellowstone universe. A potential prequel, 1944, is in the works from Taylor Sheridan, which could provide further insight into Spencer’s development as a father in a changing era.

Demonstrating Fatherly Qualities Early On

Before his journey into fatherhood commenced, Spencer displayed his aptitude for nurturing relationships with children. During a train ride to Livingston, he encountered a young boy who wished to trade a pocket knife for a lion’s tooth. Through their interaction, Spencer exhibited attentiveness, care, and respect for the boy’s curiosity, engaging him in a meaningful dialogue. This exchange not only highlighted Spencer’s character but also offered a glimpse into his potential as a father.

While Spencer’s path as a perfect father remains uncertain, his affinity for children is encouraging. His genuine excitement upon learning of Alexandra’s pregnancy indicates he is ready to embrace fatherhood. Moreover, John II symbolizes Spencer’s connection to the late Alexandra, likely deepening his affection for his son and motivating him to be the best father he can be.

Examining John Dutton’s Troubling Legacy

Comparatively, the expectations for Spencer Dutton as a father are set remarkably low, primarily due to the well-documented failings of John Dutton III as a parent. Throughout Yellowstone, John III’s portrayal included numerous instances of harshness and emotional distance from his children—Kayce, Jamie, Beth, and Lee—leading to deep-seated traumas and family estrangements. His self-serving tendencies often prioritized the ranch over his family’s emotional needs.

A Rare Redeeming Moment

It’s only towards the later stages of his life that John III demonstrated any significant paternal connection, particularly with his grandson, Tate. By this time, his age had softened his disposition, creating a stark contrast to his earlier parenting style. As long as Spencer approaches fatherhood with care instead of cruelty, he is bound to create a healthier family dynamic than John Dutton proved capable of achieving.

Support System for John Dutton II

Another factor favoring the upbringing of John II is the support he will receive from Jacob (Harrison Ford) and Cara Dutton (Helen Mirren). Both characters have exhibited their ability to nurture and care for family, suggesting that John II will benefit significantly from their guidance during his formative years.

The Role of Extended Family in John II’s Life

Jacob has indicated his willingness to step back from ranching, promising that John II will enjoy a stable family environment filled with love and attention. However, it’s worth noting that given Jacob and Cara’s advanced age, their availability to actively participate in John II’s upbringing may diminish over time. Spencer may find himself juggling ranch responsibilities while ensuring his son receives adequate care and attention.

While the early years of John II’s life may be enriched by the involvement of Jacob and Cara, the potential for their absence looms. With an uncertain future ahead and Spencer tasked with the caretaking role interwoven with ranch duties, the path forward is fraught with challenges. Even in 1923, the narrative provides glimpses of hope, yet hints at the complexities of family life amid changing times.

Source & Images