90 Day: The Last Resort enthusiasts are buzzing with speculation about a possible romance between Josh Weinstein and Jenn Potthast, the sister of Elizabeth Potthast. However, it seems this rumor may not hold water.
Josh first made his appearance in the reality series during the second season of 90 Day: The Single Life. At the time, Natalie Mordovtseva had recently relocated to Florida after her breakup with Mike Youngquist and was involved with a model named Johnny. It was during this period that Johnny took Natalie to a modeling workshop hosted by Josh’s agency, Preview Models. Following her split from Johnny, Natalie connected with Josh, leading to a golfing date.
As their relationship progressed, Natalie discovered that Josh had two children from previous relationships and was not interested in expanding his family. Despite her dreams of motherhood, Natalie opted to continue dating him. Their relationship lacked commitment, resembling more of a casual situationship rather than a serious partnership deserving of couples’ therapy. Eventually, the two separated on-air but continued to share intimate moments until Josh began seeing someone new—a fellow cast member.
Insights into Josh’s New Girlfriend
During a February interview on “The Sarah Fraser Show,”Josh confirmed his breakup with Natalie, stating, “Right now, we are friends.” He reflected on their journey, describing it as a “wild ride,” while also conveying that he still holds some care for her. Both he and Natalie have since moved on to new relationships, with Josh mentioning that he is involved with someone from the 90 Day Fiancé franchise.
Upcoming Reveal at the Tell-All
Josh Spotted with His New Girlfriend
In recent reports, Shabooty shared photos documenting Josh’s travels through the Las Vegas airport, where he was reportedly seen with a mystery woman while en route to Phoenix. The blogger speculated, “This could be his new girlfriend.” Notably, Josh traveled in “Group 1,” indicating first-class seating, and the unidentified woman brought along a small dog.
“Yes, it’s his new GF!”
Sarah Fraser, the podcast host, indicated in her comments on the blog that the woman in question is indeed Josh’s new girlfriend, and she hinted that viewers can expect to see her at the upcoming Tell All for 90 Day: The Last Resort.
A Throwback to Josh & Jenn’s Past Connection
In March 2025, a clip surfaced on social media from the blogger 90dayfianceupdate, suggesting that his mystery girlfriend might actually be Jenn Potthast. The discussion initiated with, “Has he been hiding her for years?” Fans reminisced about Jenn and pointed out that Josh knew the Potthast family, given that Elizabeth’s mother manages a casting agency. The video captured Josh and Jenn enjoying themselves on what appeared to be a lively night out.
In the clip, Josh happily pointed at the camera while holding a drink, with Jenn leaning on his shoulder, further fueling the speculations about their relationship status. Although Josh never labeled this outing as a date, the lively atmosphere and fans’ comments indicated potential interest, with opinions varying widely. Some viewers remarked that Jenn is a significant upgrade from Natalie, while others suggested this moment insinuates a future collaboration on a spin-off show.
Interestingly, the video, initially shared on Josh’s Instagram in February 2023, was later posted by a Reddit user and sparked discussions about whether Josh and Jenn were pulling a prank or genuinely together. Despite claims of being just acquaintances, the duo shared many commonalities, including their status as single parents, each having two children and Florida roots. Yet, after the footage surfaced, Josh rekindled his relationship with Natalie.
Natalie’s Revelation About Josh’s New Relationship
Natalie took to Instagram to share her perspective on comments made by Josh about her during the show. She expressed her discomfort following Josh labeling her a liar and a “scam artist” in response to claims she made regarding his ex-wife. Feeling hurt by the portrayal, she clarified that she never disrespected his family.
“At the Tell All, he introduced a new girlfriend half his age.”
Natalie suggested that Josh presented his new girlfriend during the 90 Day: The Last Resort Tell All, describing her as being half his age. Interestingly, she has been familiar with Jenn, who is not half Josh’s age. This remark raises questions about the identity of this mystery woman since the cast was clearly aware of her presence when she was introduced on stage.
90 Day: The Last Resort premieres Mondays at 9 p.m. EDT on TLC.
Source: The Sarah Fraser Show, 90 Day Fiancé/Instagram, Shabooty/Instagram, 90dayfianceupdate/Instagram, u/SignificantCamel8516/Reddit, Natalie Mordovtseva/Instagram