Explained: Sydney Sweeney’s Dark Role in The Handmaid’s Tale

Before gaining widespread recognition for her portrayal of Cassie Howard in Euphoria, Sydney Sweeney took on a profoundly darker role in The Handmaid’s Tale. This acclaimed series, set within the oppressive regime of Gilead, highlights the stripping away of women’s autonomy. Sweeney was introduced as Eden Spencer in Season 2, Episode 5, titled “Seeds.”Captivatingly tragic, Eden is forced into marriage with Nick Blaine (Max Minghella) at the tender age of 15. Her story takes a heartbreaking turn when she is executed for kissing Isaac (Rohan Mead), branded as a “sinner”in the eyes of Gilead’s harsh laws against infidelity.

Although the main narrative follows June Osborne (Elizabeth Moss), Sweeney’s character offers a poignant exploration of gender politics and women’s rights within the show’s intense framework. Sydney Sweeney is known for portraying strong and independent young women, making her a fitting choice for a series that tackles these critical issues. Eden’s demise stands as one of the most shocking moments in the series, illuminating the grim realities of Gilead earlier in the storyline.

Who Does Sydney Sweeney Play In The Handmaid’s Tale?

Sydney Sweeney Plays Eden, One of the Show’s Most Tragic Characters

Sydney Sweeney as Eden looking sad in The Handmaid's Tale

In her role as Eden Spencer, Sweeney appears across seven episodes. Her performance subtly depicts a character deeply entrenched in despair. As her story unfolds, it begins to resemble a horror narrative; initially, Eden begins sharing a living space with Nick, only to face a devastating fate later. Her tragic end arises from a betrayal by her father while attempting to escape Gilead with Isaac in the Season 2 finale, “Postpartum.”

Despite the oppressive environment Gilead creates, Eden exhibits remarkable strength by choosing death over admitting guilt. This decision reverberates throughout the series, especially affecting June, who witnesses firsthand the grave dangers that Gilead poses to women’s desires for love and autonomy.

The Dark Ending of Eden’s Handmaid’s Tale Character Arc

Eden Is Publicly Executed

Isaac and Eden talking in The Handmaid's Tale

Eden’s fate is sealed in the episode “Postpartum,”where she and Isaac face the horrific reality of execution. On a diving board over a pool, weighted and chained, both characters must confront their choices. Eden’s chance at salvation hinges on her willingness to confess a sin she did not commit—a perilous conundrum that mirrors the struggles of all women in Gilead. Nick, fully aware of the horrific consequences of defiance, is powerless to save her.

The oppressive societal conditioning in Gilead illustrates a harsh truth: many characters, including Nick, have internalized the belief that their reality is immutable. Ultimately, Eden’s choice to accept death is a devastating act of resistance—a means to attain some semblance of peace amid despair.

Eden’s tragic awareness of her position reflects on the systematic oppression women face, underscored by the shocking revelation that her father is the source of her demise. His loyalty to the regime blinds him to his daughter’s suffering. This theme of betrayal acts as a critical backdrop to the overall narrative, emphasizing the struggles of individuals caught in such a regime.

What Is Eden’s Impact On The Handmaid’s Tale Story?

The Death of Sydney Sweeney’s Eden Is a Huge Catalyst for the Narrative

Eden and June sitting and talking on a couch in The Handmaid's Tale

Eden’s death serves as a pivotal turning point within the series, impacting the character arcs of several key players. For instance, Serena Joy Waterford (Yvonne Strahovski), who originally encourages the union between Eden and Nick, is left to grapple with the guilt stemming from Eden’s demise. This painful reality evolves Serena’s character, allowing her vulnerability to surface, particularly in her relationship with June.

Moreover, Eden’s presence influences June’s motivation to protect her own child, Nichole, from Gilead’s horrors, staying steadfast in her resolve to ensure Nichole’s safety in Canada. While June’s ties to Nick mirror Eden’s constraints, June’s narrative unfolds in clearly defined contrasts. Eden’s longing for romantic affection ultimately leads to her tragic end, while June remains determined to navigate the oppressive landscape of Gilead with hope and resilience.

Sydney Sweeney’s Handmaid’s Tale Character Is An Econoperson – Here’s What That Means

Eden Represents One of Gilead’s Most Dystopian Features

Sydney Sweeney as Eden in white in The Handmaid's Tale

Though the titular characters of the series capture the limelight, Sydney Sweeney’s Eden is emblematic of an even darker socio-economic reality. As an “econoperson,”SHE has limited choices and embodies the plight faced by lower-class women within Gilead’s strict hierarchical society. The hardships of being an econoperson showcase the limitations imposed not only on handmaids but also on women like Eden who are slated for marriages devoid of love or autonomy.

In contrast to handmaids, whose primary role revolves around child-rearing, econopersons must juggle multiple functions within the home. For example, econowives are tasked with fulfilling the roles of wives and caregivers, in addition to their responsibilities as housekeepers. This stark reality leads to situations where individuals, like Sweeney’s Eden, are taken from their families merely for compliance with the regime’s expectations.

A broader issue for econopeople is a culture of betrayal, where personal allegiances falter in favor of advancing one’s station. As is the case with Eden, familial bonds fail to shield her from harm, illustrating a chilling aspect of Gilead’s oppressive structure.

How Does Sweeney’s Handmaid’s Tale Role Compare to Her Euphoria Part?

Sydney Sweeney’s Characters Share Many Common Traits

None
None
None
None
None

Both Sydney Sweeney’s characters in Euphoria and The Handmaid’s Tale navigate complicated relationships filled with emotional intensity. In , Cassie finds herself entangled with her friend Maddie’s boyfriend, Nate Jacobs (Jacob Elordi), which leads to a tumultuous and often toxic love narrative. In contrast, Eden’s quest for love and freedom leads to tragic outcomes as well.

While their respective arcs diverge in context, the core struggle remains similar: both characters seek validation and affection in environments that often reject them. Sydney Sweeney’s ability to embody these emotional vulnerabilities across genres showcases her versatile acting prowess.

What Sydney Sweeney Said About Her Handmaid’s Tale Role

Sweeney Had No Idea What Her Character’s Fate Was Going To Be

Eden talking outside to Nick on The Handmaid's Tale

Throughout her burgeoning career, Sydney Sweeney has embraced challenging roles, transitioning from The Handmaid’s Tale to Euphoria, which tackle profound and often dark societal themes. Interestingly, she was initially unaware of the fate that awaited her character in The Handmaid’s Tale.

“I knew she was going to have an ending. I wasn’t exactly sure how it was going to end. There was [the idea of], ‘Oh, she could end up running away.’ They weren’t quite sure what direction they were going in. I just knew there was going to be an ending. When I read episode 12, I was completely shocked… I was screaming at the page [while] reading.”

Upon reflecting on Eden’s tragic conclusion, Sweeney expressed appreciation for the show’s unflinching depiction of horror, emphasizing its impact on audiences. “I was glad that it went so dark for an ending. Because it’s going to hit a lot of people and have a huge impact,”she noted. Recognizing the weight of her character’s fate, she acknowledges its significance, carrying storylines into future seasons while celebrating her experience working on impactful, women-led productions.

“I’ve looked up to Amy Adams, Patricia Clarkson, and Elisabeth Moss for years and years … Being able to work with all of them in one year has been phenomenal. Also, being able to be a part of shows that mean so much and are changing Hollywood has been really cool, too.”

Source & Images

© 2021 The Filibuster Blog