The much-anticipated album featuring Elton John and Brandi Carlile has finally landed. This release marks the 33rd studio album for Elton John, a legendary figure in the music industry, while it serves as Brandi Carlile’s eighth. Both artists have made significant impacts in the rock genre, with Carlile being a rising star and John enjoying a revered legacy.
The collaboration between John and Carlile has generated considerable excitement, as many fans were eager to discover the musical synergy between these two distinct yet complementary artists. Their partnership promised a unique experience, and the resulting album does not fall short of expectations. To truly appreciate the album’s offerings, let’s delve into a ranking of its songs from least to most impressive.
10 A Little Light
Track #8
This track ushers Elton John into a more country-inspired realm, characteristic of Brandi Carlile’s musical style. While the venture into traditional country may seem appealing, this particular sound does not align well with Carlile’s artistic identity. Consequently, John’s usual vocal prowess seems somewhat diminished here.
While no one can deny the chemistry between John and Carlile, this track feels less polished compared to others on the album. The absence of Carlile’s distinctive style makes the song resonate as somewhat generic, ultimately not doing justice to either of the artists’ talents.
9 Someone to Belong To
Track #9
Following the previous track, “Someone to Belong To” presents a more emotionally compelling experience. Its heartfelt lyrics resonate deeply with listeners and arguably rank among the finest lyrical compositions on the album. However, strong writing alone doesn’t guarantee success, as performance and instrumentation must also shine.
This track features contributions from Brandi Carlile, Elton John, Bernie Taupin, and producer Andrew Watt, yet it doesn’t deliver the impactful performance typical of their collaborations. Although it’s possible that its appeal may develop with repeated listens, its initial presentation struggles to blend seamlessly with the album’s overall theme.
8 Never Too Late
Track #4
Transitioning from three high-energy tracks, this song slows down to deliver a folk-oriented duet. The abrupt shift in tempo can be jarring, but once listeners settle into the rhythm, John and Carlile’s powerful voices create an entrancing experience.
The duo’s collaboration proves to be a highlight, capturing attention despite the sudden drop in pace. Their chemistry maintains the listener’s interest, showcasing both artists’ talents in a welcoming way.
7 Little Richard’s Bible
Track #2
While the track shines as a quintessential Elton John piece, it falls short of being a true collaboration, which may disappoint fans looking for a collaborative showcase from the two Grammy winners.
6 Swing for the Fences
Track #3
In “Swing for the Fences,” Brandi Carlile steps into her element, showcasing her folk and country roots. The lively sound, enhanced by John’s backup vocals, serves to elevate Carlile’s performance without overshadowing her presence. This collaborative effort allows both artists to shine.
This track exemplifies the benefits of their partnership, merging unique flavors of each artist to produce an original sound that captivates listeners.
5 You Without Me
Track #5
Among the album’s tracks, “You Without Me” stands out as one of the few featuring only Brandi Carlile. While some may find it disappointing to lack a duet, the song’s intrinsic quality shines through. Carlile injects a profound emotional intensity into her solo performance, making it a compelling listen.
Despite its standalone nature, it could arguably rival several collaboration tracks, reflecting her artistry and passion.
4 The River Man
Track #7
Listeners are treated to an uplifting experience as the song transforms into a celebratory anthem, energizing them and evoking a sense of motivation.
3 The Rose of Laura Nyro
Track #1
As the opening track, “The Rose of Laura Nyro” sets the stage with a grand instrumental introduction. The first two minutes captivate with a purely instrumental section, building anticipation for the vocal harmonies that follow.
When the vocals do emerge, Carlile and John’s harmonies blend seamlessly, showcasing an energetic synergy reminiscent of some of John’s most celebrated works. This track serves as a powerful prelude to the rest of the album, hinting at its depth and potential.
2 Who Believes in Angels
Track #6
The titular track “Who Believes in Angels” emerges as a pivotal moment in the album, embodying its essence and emotional weight. It stands out not just as a key reflection of the album’s themes but also as one of its finest offerings.
Featuring both John and Carlile on vocals and instrumentation, the track reveals a beautiful interplay between the artists and is enhanced by an array of additional instruments, creating an engaging musical tapestry.
1 When This Old World is Done With Me
Track #10
In a poignant twist, the two best tracks on the album are performed solo by each artist. Elton John’s “When This Old World is Done With Me” concludes the album on a high note, resonating deeply as a reflective farewell to his storied career.
Though it doesn’t mark the end of John’s journey, it captures a bittersweet acknowledgment of the passing of time. The emotional depth of this final track lingers with listeners long after the album concludes, serving as a powerful closing statement in the collaborative effort of Elton John and Brandi Carlile.