Overview
- Midoriya’s victory over Overhaul using Eri’s Quirk has led to polarized opinions due to perceived absence of repercussions.
- The unexpected killing of Twice by Hawks stirred controversy, prompting fans to question his moral standards.
- Nighteye’s death was deemed hasty given the power of his Quirk, creating mixed reactions about his character’s exit.
My Hero Academia has garnered immense popularity among anime fans, yet it is not without its share of controversial moments. The creative risks taken by Horikoshi have sparked discussions and debates among viewers. While divisive elements can enhance narrative dynamics, they may also leave audiences more divided than ever. In this deep dive, we will explore some of the most contentious scenes from the series. Please note that major spoilers are ahead, spanning the entirety of the manga.
Warning: Spoilers Ahead!
8. Midoriya Utilizes Eri’s Quirk to Defeat Overhaul
Midoriya Overcomes Overhaul with Eri’s Assistance
- Episode: 76
In high-stakes battles, Midoriya traditionally endures considerable strain to unleash his full potential. However, against Overhaul, this dynamic changed. With Eri utilizing her Rewind Quirk, Midoriya was able to maintain his maximum power without suffering the usual physical consequences, allowing him to easily defeat Overhaul, even when he transformed into a massive beast.
While this clever twist made for an exciting conclusion, many fans felt it undermined Midoriya’s character growth, as the lack of physical strain suggested minimal consequences for his actions.
7. Hawks Executes Twice
Hawks’ Actions Spark Moral Dilemmas
- Episode: 116
Hawks emerged as a complex character in the Pro Hero arc, depicted as someone willing to take drastic measures to uphold the law. However, his cold-blooded murder of Twice, a character known for his affability within the League of Villains, shocked fans and raised questions about Hawks’ ethical boundaries.
While the rationale behind the act was clear—Twice’s potential for mass destruction—many fans were unsettled by the execution of the act, especially considering its repercussions throughout the series.
6. Nighteye’s Tragic Demise
Fans Perceived Nighteye’s Departure as Premature
- Episode: 77
Nighteye, known for his remarkable Foresight Quirk, met an untimely end during the Overhaul arc, only a few episodes after his introduction. His death was profoundly emotional, especially as he expressed faith in Midoriya as All Might’s successor before his passing.
Fans lamented this loss, feeling it squandered Nighteye’s potential significance in subsequent story arcs. Speculation abounds that Horikoshi opted to eliminate such a powerful character to prevent narrative complications, but this choice left many viewers frustrated.
5. Mirio Recovers His Quirk
Mirio Regains His Quirk with Eri’s Help
- Episode: 125
Mirio’s heart-wrenching loss of his Quirk due to a Quirk-Destroying Bullet was among the series’ low points. However, his sudden recovery during the climactic war, thanks to Eri’s Rewind Quirk, allowed him to rejoin the fight against Shigaraki.
While this outcome thrilled fans who longed to see Mirio’s prowess displayed again, others felt it diminished the emotional gravity of his earlier loss and character development.
4. Star and Stripe’s Fate
Fans Question the Relevance of Star and Stripe
- Episode: 140
Star and Stripe, introduced as America’s number one hero with a unique Quirk, faced criticism for her limited screen time. After only one fight, she perished at the hands of Shigaraki, leaving many fans feeling her character was underutilized.
While her brief involvement showcased her capabilities against a formidable opponent, her early removal left some fans perplexed regarding her narrative purpose in the overarching story.
3. Students Forgive the U.A. Traitor
Shock Over Aoyama’s Quick Redemption
- Episode: 141
The reveal of Aoyama as a traitor working for All For One was a staggering twist. However, the rapid forgiveness he received from Midoriya and his classmates drew criticism. His betrayal had severe implications, potentially compromising the students’ safety multiple times throughout the series.
Although the students’ willingness to forgive reflected themes of compassion, many fans felt the resolution was too swift and lacked the gravity the situation warranted, especially with the impending threat from the villains.
2. Midoriya Inherits Previous Users’ Quirks
The Sudden Introduction of Blackwhip Raises Eyebrows
- Episode: 98
The notion of Midoriya inheriting the Quirks of former One For All users was subtly hinted, but its revelation coupled with Blackwhip’s sudden appearance prompted significant debate among fans. Some expressed concerns about Midoriya’s potentially overwhelming power, fearing it would undermine his struggle.
Conversely, others viewed this development as an exciting opportunity for character growth, with expectations that Midoriya would learn to balance and master multiple Quirks throughout the narrative.
1. Bakugo’s Ultimate Sacrifice
Did Bakugo’s Death Need to Happen?
- Episode: 150
Bakugo’s climactic confrontation with Shigaraki showcased his evolution as a hero. The moment he seemingly sacrifices himself, facing a lifeless end at the villain’s hands, struck a poignant chord. This moment could have served as a powerful narrative closure for his character arc.
However, the subsequent resurrection by Edgeshot generated a mix of joy and frustration among fans. While some celebrated Bakugo’s return, others confronted a missed opportunity to elevate the stakes and solidify his heroic journey through ultimate sacrifice.