Amy Sherman-Palladino Reflects on “Strange” Network Feedback for ‘Gilmore Girls’: “Why Isn’t Rory Experiencing Romance?”

A Night to Celebrate Amy Sherman-Palladino at PaleyFest LA

On a vibrant Saturday night, the iconic worlds of *Gilmore Girls*, *The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel*, and the upcoming series *Étoile* converged at PaleyFest LA, honoring the illustrious creator, Amy Sherman-Palladino. This event, titled “The Amy Sherman-Palladino Multiverse,”featured a host of beloved actors, including Lauren Graham and Kelly Bishop from *Gilmore Girls*, and Rachel Brosnahan, Alex Borstein, and Luke Kirby from *Maisel*, alongside Charlotte Gainsbourg and Lou de Laâge from *Étoile*.

Hosted at the legendary Dolby Theatre in Hollywood, the gathering provided an engaging 90-minute discussion reflecting on Sherman-Palladino’s rich career, complemented by insights from her husband and writing partner, Daniel Palladino.

From Dancer to Writer: The Birth of a Creative Visionary

The conversation began with Sherman-Palladino recounting her early days as a dancer and her initial foray into writing for the acclaimed sitcom *Roseanne*. With characteristic humor, she reminisced, “*Roseanne* was an extraordinarily special show at the time. First of all, [Roseanne Barr] was only her first version of crazy; it’s very different now.” This anecdote set the tone for a fascinating look into her life and career.

She further shared the inception of *Gilmore Girls*, revealing that she was initially pitching a different project when she spontaneously described her idea about a mother-daughter duo who were more like friends. To her surprise, the pitch resonated, leading to the development of the beloved series.

The Journey of Casting and Collaboration

Both Graham and Bishop discussed their respective paths to joining *Gilmore Girls*. Graham’s casting as Lorelai was notably complicated by her involvement in another project, leading Sherman-Palladino to express reluctance in meeting her out of fear of becoming too attached. “I didn’t want to fall in love with her… if I can’t have her, I don’t want to know that she exists,” she explained humorously. However, a fortunate turn of events allowed Graham to join the cast, with her later learning that network executives had “traded” her for another actress.

Despite its later success, *Gilmore Girls* faced significant hurdles during its production. Sherman-Palladino recounted receiving weekly calls from the studio expressing dissatisfaction with the show, only to have the studio send her flowers upon the premiere of the pilot after she firmly requested they either let her go or stop calling.

The creator highlighted the resistance she faced regarding the show’s narrative choices, particularly around themes of teenage sexuality and maternal responsibilities. “There was a lot of pushback… ‘Why isn’t Rory having sex?’ Well, because she’s in high school!” she declared, drawing laughter from the audience.

Behind-the-Scenes Challenges and Community Engagement

Reflecting on the limited budget during production, Sherman-Palladino joked about the generosity of *The Drew Carey Show*, which would share food and water with the *Gilmore* team. She humorously recalled walking in circles around Burbank, showcasing their resourcefulness in overcoming financial constraints to create the show’s enchanting universe that was meant to depict Connecticut life.

The conversation shifted towards the enduring legacy of *Gilmore Girls*, especially since it became available for streaming on Netflix. Graham shared heartfelt stories from fans, noting how the series has fostered connections among family members during challenging times. “It helped us get through a rough time,” she reflected, emphasizing the show’s role as a comforting touchstone for many.

Looking Ahead: *Bunheads*, *Maisel*, and the Anticipation of *Étoile*

The evening turned to Sherman-Palladino’s subsequent projects, including her 2012 series *Bunheads*, which received a special mention through a video message from star Sutton Foster. The discussion also celebrated *The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel*, which has garnered an impressive 22 Emmy wins over five seasons. Borstein playfully remarked that her career feels complete now, to which Sherman-Palladino humorously responded that the conversation of retirement was off the table.

As the night concluded with a preview of *Étoile*, Palladino shared insights into the new Prime Video series focusing on the artistic journey of ballet companies in New York and Paris. “We’re really interested in the dynamic and the struggle to do it, the interchange, the sexual hijinks,” she explained, highlighting a narrative centered on the complexities of professional relationships within the performing arts.

Mark your calendars! *Étoile* premieres on April 24, promising to bring a fresh and captivating story to audiences.

Source & Images

© 2021 The Filibuster Blog