Renowned even among those unfamiliar with anime, Naruto has emerged as one of the genre’s crowning achievements. As part of the esteemed “Big Three” —alongside it the likes of Bleach and One Piece—Naruto’s influence is undeniable. This iconic series not only set a benchmark for shōnen anime but also introduced an unprecedented blend of compelling storytelling, exhilarating battles, and memorable characters that many subsequent series aspire to emulate.
With the conclusion of Naruto, fans are eager for the next generation of shōnen anime. Among the standout series that have gained traction since the end of Naruto are Black Clover and My Hero Academia. While these three series share numerous themes and elements, it is noteworthy that one of them doesn’t enjoy the same level of esteem as the others.
Naruto’s Lasting Impact on Shōnen Anime
The Legacy of a Legendary Series
Naruto’s legacy is solidified as one of the greatest anime series, with both Naruto and Naruto: Shippuden showcasing consistent quality throughout their runs. Following Naruto’s evolution from a village outcast to the strongest ninja is a journey filled with emotional depth and excitement, making it a beloved experience for anime enthusiasts.
Naruto unintentionally became a cornerstone of the shōnen genre. Similar to the legendary Dragon Ball Z, Naruto’s impact has been profound and wide-reaching. When fans think of shōnen anime, Naruto is likely one of the first titles that springs to mind.
The exceptional success of Naruto has raised expectations for newer series. Spanning over 700 episodes, both Naruto and its sequel demonstrated the epitome of action-packed storytelling, setting a high bar that other shōnen series are often measured against—sometimes quite harshly.
Black Clover: Unfair Comparisons to Naruto
Navigating the “Clone”Label
Black Clover has rapidly established itself as an essential part of modern shōnen, particularly attractive to newcomers. This series features a straightforward narrative, a diverse cast with distinct personalities, and some of the most thrilling fight sequences in anime.
The central narrative chronicles Asta, a young boy born without magic in a world steeped in magical prowess. Contrary to initial expectations, Asta’s lack of magical abilities ultimately transforms into a defining strength, allowing for dynamic character development throughout the series.
Through sheer determination, Asta harnesses Anti-Magic, one of the most formidable forces within Black Clover. His evolution from the weakest character to a celebrated hero, thanks to hard work and the support of those who recognize his potential, forms the crux of the narrative.
The similarities between Asta and Naruto are palpable; both characters start as outcasts, advocate for forgiveness, and create profound connections with others. Nevertheless, such comparisons often lead to Black Clover being labeled as a “Naruto Clone”, an unjust label for a series that is carving its unique path.
My Hero Academia: Similarities and Inconsistencies in Critique
Critiquing the Double Standards
My Hero Academia also follows a narrative path strikingly similar to that of Black Clover, yet the latter rarely receives the same backlash. Centered around Izuku Midoriya, a character born without Quirks in a world where they reign supreme, the story reflects themes of perseverance and self-discovery.
Like Asta, Midoriya eventually acquires one of the most powerful Quirks, showcasing his unwavering commitment to growth and protecting others—traits that resonate strongly with fans. The passion and determination of these protagonists draw parallels that are difficult to overlook.
Black Clover and My Hero Academia share numerous thematic elements, as do both series with Naruto. With all three dealing with the universal themes of perseverance and heroism, it raises the question: why does Black Clover face such disproportionate criticism?
Reevaluating the “Clone”Narrative
Appreciating Unique Contributions
Neither Black Clover nor My Hero Academia rightfully merit the label of Naruto clones. Such a characterization diminishes the individuality and creativity that each series brings to the table. This narrow view neglects the distinct storytelling and world-building that define each anime.
While Naruto certainly serves as an inspiration for both series, it is important to recognize that admiration does not equate to mimicry. Artists, creators, and writers can draw influences from one another without losing their unique identity, similar to how a painter is inspired by the masterpieces of their predecessors.
Each series—focusing on ninjas, magic users, and superheroes—offers a unique perspective on their respective worlds and challenges, contributing to their respective joys and narratives.
Celebrating Black Clover’s Individuality
Understanding the Popular Appeal
Black Clover deserves recognition rather than unjust criticism. It ranks among the most popular series on MyAnimeList.com, demonstrating its wide appeal and devoted fanbase eagerly awaiting its next chapter.
Asta may come across as loud and occasionally naive, reflecting traits seen in many beloved heroes—such as Goku from Dragon Ball. His earnestness and determination to see the good in everyone, despite his flaws, aligns with classic shōnen tropes.
Watch the analysis here
To unfairly label Asta as simply a Naruto copy overlooks the deeper nuances present in character development across series. My Hero Academia continues to thrive; however, it remains perplexing why it avoids the same level of scrutiny that has consistently been directed at Black Clover.
Ultimately, it’s time for fans to acknowledge that Black Clover does not deserve the criticisms it faces. By embracing its uniqueness and celebrating its narratives, anime lovers can create a more inclusive space for all series within the vibrant world of shōnen.