After watching the initial three episodes of Fullmetal Alchemist, I have found myself pleasantly surprised and my overall perception of the series has significantly improved. Many of the notions I previously held, which led to a negative assessment, have proven to be unfounded. However, one element that has reaffirmed my critique lies in the intricate dynamics of the brothers Ed and Alphonse Elric’s relationship—something that may not align with what most fans anticipate.
Exploring the Elric Brothers: Expectations vs. Reality
The Superficial Nature of Ed and Al’s Present-Day Conflicts
While I do not believe their brotherly bond is poorly constructed—in fact, their tragic origin story is among the most heartbreaking—I find the current interactions between Ed and Al somewhat lacking in depth. My primary concern lies not in their past traumas, which undeniably impact their actions, but rather in the nature of their present-day relationship, which appears to be somewhat superficial.
To me, the most compelling relationships are those grounded in current conflicts alongside past experiences. While their shared history significantly shapes Ed and Al’s bond, the present-day tensions primarily emerge from comedic scenarios, such as Ed’s height complex and the fact that Al’s soul resides in a suit of armor. This dynamic is humorous but not particularly substantial, as the misidentification of Al as the “Fullmetal Alchemist”stems from his appearance rather than his true identity.
For this element of their relationship to transition from mere comedic fodder to something more meaningful, it needs to evolve beyond physical characteristics and reflect deeper aspects of Al’s character. As the series progresses, I anticipate this dynamic will develop, which often occurs in well-crafted narratives. However, as it stands within these first three episodes, their relationship feels defined by their past rather than any present conflict, which leaves me wanting more.
Ed Elric: An Evolving Hero in Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
An Unexpected Revelation About Ed Elric
Aside from this critique, my experience thus far has allowed me to appreciate Fullmetal Alchemist far more than I anticipated. I had held a misconception about Ed’s character for years—a misunderstanding that was clarified in the pivotal second episode. I used to believe that Ed’s prodigious talents, at such a young age, detracted from his relatability, particularly because I favor underdog narratives.
Ironically, I enjoy characters like Goku, who defy the underdog trope, so my original annoyance with Ed is curious. I suspect that my oversaturation with shows like Dragon Ball influenced my perception, as I have since found many of Naruto’s trials more engaging than a character who is innately powerful. However, it turns out Ed’s abilities primarily derive from an encounter with a mysterious and unnamed being during a Human Transmutation ritual.
This divine intervention in Ed’s journey adds a layer of intrigue to his character development. It resembles the narrative arcs seen in contemporary series like My Hero Academia and Black Clover, where powers are gifted rather than earned—an approach I admire and find refreshing. This newfound understanding has convinced me that Ed Elric is indeed one of the standout heroes in shonen literature.
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood’s Layered World Beyond Homunculi
Isaac the Freezer and the Expanding Universe of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
Another appealing aspect of the series, which I have always admired despite my lack of viewership, is the Homunculi. Finally introduced in episode three of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, these characters promise to heighten the stakes for Ed and Al as they navigate their military quests. Initially, I assumed that their most significant challenges would arise from these formidable foes, but I now appreciate the intricate complexities that these adversaries introduce to the overarching plot.
As the series unfolds, I eagerly await the potential conspiracies tied to the Homunculi, as anime often thrives on interconnected narratives. I suspect that these storylines could contribute to Roy Mustang’s eventual pursuit of the Elric brothers, given his alignment with major plot elements—a subject I find particularly intriguing.
While my past memories of Fullmetal Alchemist might not be entirely accurate, my excitement for future developments, particularly the pending conflict between Roy and the brothers, is growing. Their current rapport offers a strong foundation for whatever tensions may arise.
In conclusion, it is becoming increasingly clear why Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood garners praise as one of the greatest anime series of all time. My opinions have transformed in just three episodes, and despite my critiques regarding Ed and Al’s relationship dynamics, I recognize that my expectations might have influenced my perspective. As my journey through the series continues, I anticipate my views may evolve even further.