Assassin’s Creed Shadows stands out as the series’ most impressive stealth installment since the franchise’s inception. It introduces an expansive stealth sandbox environment, a wider array of tools for players, and compelling world dynamics that alter the gameplay experience. Factors such as changing seasons, ambient lighting, and varied map layouts enhance how missions are approached. This evolution marks a significant improvement over its predecessors, particularly in comparison to Valhalla. For gamers yearning for an authentic assassination experience, this title delivers precisely that.
One of the standout features of Shadows is its flexibility. An excellent illustration of this is the option to enable a guaranteed assassination attempt, allowing players to eliminate targeted enemies instantly, regardless of their health status. This feature not only caters to players’ preferences but also positions Shadows as superior to titles like Ghost of Tsushima. Yet, miss opportunities for further improvements are evident, as Ubisoft could have integrated additional valuable gameplay elements.
Unfair Assassination Denials in Assassin’s Creed Shadows
Assassination Attempts Denied Due to Level Disparities

The Guaranteed Assassination mechanic undoubtedly enhances immersion for players who believe a stealthy approach should result in a swift, lethal blow rather than merely reducing an enemy’s health. This feature simplifies the stealth experience, providing a welcome benefit for those who may find it challenging. However, the game’s most significant flaw remains the occasional denial of assassination attempts. Specific scenarios arise where enemies can evade being assassinated, particularly if the player approaches from a detectable angle.
While the foundation of this mechanic encourages strategic thinking about navigation and enemy placement, it raises eyebrows when enemies can deny attacks from above. The notion that a skilled assassin could be countered by a soldier unaware of their descent defies plausibility. It seems unlikely that a soldier would successfully evade a downward strike aimed at their neck, highlighting a disconnect in the game’s logic.
Other AC Shadows Assassination Limitations MakeSense
Allowing Players to Inflict Damage

The inconsistency of denied assassinations from above not only disrupts Assassin’s Creed Shadows’ immersion but can also lead to player frustration during stealth gameplay. Ascending roofs, waiting for the appropriate moment, and then being thwarted by a seemingly superhuman adversary is counterintuitive, particularly when facing larger, slower foes. Ubisoft should have implemented an option to bypass denied assassinations from above, allowing players to inflict some damage on tougher enemies rather than facing complete failure.
This approach would still preserve the challenge of the game while ensuring that players feel rewarded for their strategic efforts. Currently, if Naoe reaches Knowledge Rank 5, she can unlock the Hand Of The Creed ability, which mitigates some assassination denials, but this requires time and progression, leaving players grappling with denied attempts for an extensive portion of the gameplay.
While the inclusion of denied assassinations serves a purpose in fostering tension within the game, Assassin’s Creed Shadows should enable players to inflict at least minor damage during surprise attacks. A mechanism where Naoe briefly stabs or wounds enemies, only to be repelled, would enhance realism, maintain immersion, and mitigate player frustrations amidst an otherwise effective stealth system.
An Overemphasis on Levels in Assassin’s Creed
Impact on Gameplay Dynamics

A primary reason behind the implementation of denied assassinations revolves around the game’s focus on level-gating. Enemies permitted to reject assassinations are often higher-level, thus deemed to possess superior reaction speeds by the game’s standards. While this level-oriented approach can enhance some aspects of gameplay, it detracts from essential mechanics that should remain intuitive.
The process of executing a successful assassination already involves significant planning, effort, and stealth. From climbing rooftops to finding the optimal attack position, players invest considerable energy into their approach. This should warrant at least a token reward, such as inflicting damage upon execution. Historically, the franchise rewarded players for their stealth efforts, and the presence of denied assassinations undermines that foundation. If Assassin’s Creed Shadows is committed to maintaining this mechanic, a toggle option to minimize its detriments would be a sensible addition.
Source: Access The Animus/YouTube