Will Smith is making a comeback in the music world with his new album, Based on a True Story. The multifaceted artist, who achieved fame as a rapper and later won an Oscar for his acting, is returning to his roots. It’s worth noting that he began his journey in the spotlight as a rapper alongside DJ Jazzy Jeff, and they were notably the first to win the Grammy Award for Best Rap Performance. Now, after a two-decade hiatus from music, Smith is embracing the underground scene once again.
This album, his fifth studio release, arrives 20 years after his last. Although he made an attempt to return in 2018 with an unfinished project that never saw the light of day, Based on a True Story marks an important milepost in his career. This iteration of Will Smith is markedly different, showcasing personal growth and, surprisingly, the inclusion of explicit language in his verses. Without further ado, let’s delve into the album by ranking its tracks from least to most impressive.
11
“Work of Art”feat. Jaden and Russ
Will Smith Ends the Album on a Dour Note
A collaboration between Will and Jaden Smith is a rare and significant event, given their limited appearances together on screen and in music. “Work of Art”is particularly momentous as it is their first official duet. Unfortunately, while its position as the final track (aside from an epilogue) suggests a grand conclusion, it does not fully deliver. While Smith opens with a compelling verse, the energy wanes thereafter, leaving listeners wanting more, especially from Russ and Jaden, whose contributions do not elevate the track.
10
“Hard Times (Smile)”feat. Teyana Taylor
The Most Disappointing Track on Will Smith’s Album
In this track, Will Smith’s verses fall short against the remarkable Teyana Taylor, who effortlessly handles the chorus. While her performance shines, Smith’s contributions are notably weak—feeling dated rather than contemporary. His lyrical references, like a 15-year-old nod to Drake’s “Fancy,”seem out of place; instead of bringing a fresh perspective, they come off as stale. Although a collaboration between these two talented individuals had great potential, it ultimately disappoints due to Smith’s less impactful bars.
9
“You Lookin’ For Me?”
This track kicks off with a subtle beat but transitions to more aggressive production that complements Will’s faster rhymes. Lyrically, he aims to resonate with current times, discussing his fame and relevance amid ongoing controversies. However, while the references to social media help modernize his image, they fail to leave a lasting impression. Smith’s delivery is memorable, but the overall content lacks depth, illustrating classic puffery without inviting deeper reflection.
8
“Beautiful Scars”feat. Big Sean and OBanga
Will Smith Gets Outshined by One of His Features
“Beautiful Scars”was introduced as a single and garnered attention due to its association with marketing efforts tied to Smith’s Matrix-themed music video. Yet, the track does not meet expectations lyrically, especially when compared to Big Sean’s commanding presence. While it’s common to hold returning artists to different standards, the sharp contrast in performance highlights how Smith is still finding his footing in the current rap landscape.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jWYQmPZrkOkhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jWYQmPZrkOk
7
“Int. Barbershop – Day”feat. DJ Jazzy Jeff and B. Simone
Will Smith’s Intro Sets the Tone for the Rest of the Album
Kicking off with an introspective approach, Will Smith reflects on his controversies in collaboration with DJ Jazzy Jeff and comedian B. Simone. This introduction establishes a fresh narrative, setting the stage for a new musical phase for Smith. It speaks volumes that he doesn’t shy away from discussing the complexities surrounding his life and career, marking a bold departure from his previous stances. The nostalgia of the duo working together again adds to the excitement.
6
“Bulletproof”feat. Jac Ross
The Featured Artist Doesn’t Fit Will Smith’s Bragging Tone
In a track where Smith takes a braggadocious tone—unusual for the traditionally humble actor—he affirms his resilience against adversity. Lines celebrating his status are impactful, showcasing some of his sharpest verses on the album. However, the chemistry with Jac Ross doesn’t translate well, as there is a noticeable disconnect between Ross’s inspirational hook and Smith’s confident bravado. This creates an inconsistency that diminishes the overall experience.
5
“You Can Make It”feat. Fridayy and Sunday Service Choir
Will Smith’s Inspiring Sentiment Overcomes Some Lackluster Elements
True to his motivational style, Will delivers an uplifting message in “You Can Make It.”Supported by an introspective interlude, this song champions overcoming life’s obstacles. Although it suffers from similar issues seen in “Bulletproof,”particularly the autotune-heavy chorus, Smith’s heartfelt lyrics keep it afloat. Ultimately, the song’s positive message resonates, making it a more impactful listen than some of the album’s other entries.
4
“Rave in the Wasteland”
An Old School Rapper in Will Smith Adopts a New School Sound
This track stands out as Smith embraces a vibrant and energetic sound, guided by a thematic sermon that invites listeners into a spirited atmosphere. “Rave in the Wasteland”showcases Smith’s willingness to innovate, diverging from his traditional style to explore contemporary rhythms. It reveals his desire to push boundaries, marking a refreshing step in his musical journey.
3
“Make It Look Easy”
Will Smith’s Attempt at Reggaeton is a Win
In an exciting turn, Will Smith ventures into the realm of afrobeats—a genre gaining massive popularity in today’s music scene. His seamless flow over upbeat rhythms exemplifies his adaptability and musical evolution. The track delivers infectious energy that invites listeners to enjoy the rhythm, even with an unidentified feature in the chorus that slightly distracts. Nonetheless, it successfully captures the upbeat spirit and charm that Smith is known for.
2
“Tantrum”feat. Joyner Lucas
No Other Song on This Album Sees Will Smith So Fired Up
“Tantrum”is a high-energy track showcasing both Will Smith and Joyner Lucas exchanging clever and fiery bars. The vivid imagery in their lyrics captivates, with Smith’s poignant line standing out strikingly. This song effectively embodies the spirit of competitive rap, displaying a dynamic that excites and invigorates. “Tantrum”elevates itself to one of the peak experiences of the album, demonstrating Will’s ability to still engage with potent lyricism.
1
“First Love”feat. India Martinez and Marcin
A Passionate Love Ballad from Will Smith
Following the intensity of “Tantrum,””First Love”presents a poignant contrast that allows Smith to channel his aggression into a tender exploration of love. The lyrics reflect a deep emotional journey and are beautifully complemented by India Martinez’s compelling vocals. The collaboration achieves a harmonious blend that resonates powerfully, making it a timeless piece reminiscent of Smith’s classic work from the 90s and 2000s. In this track, Will successfully merges old school charm with contemporary themes, resulting in an undeniable masterpiece.