Demon Slayer Criticism: Why Its Biggest Flaws Are Less Impactful Compared to Other Series

Demon Slayer has firmly established itself as a hallmark of modern anime over the past decade. Even as the storyline nears its conclusion, it continues to serve as an inviting gateway for newcomers keen to explore the anime genre. The show’s appeal lies in various factors, prominently featuring its simplistic yet engaging narrative that allows viewers to easily distinguish between heroes and villains.

In addition to its storytelling, the series captivates audiences with outstanding visuals. Few anime can rival the beauty and vibrancy seen in Demon Slayer. The color palettes are harmonious, enhancing the viewing experience, largely thanks to the exceptional efforts of Ufotable. However, one point of contention among fans is the representation of the breathing techniques used by the characters.

Many enthusiasts express their discontent with how the breathing styles are visualized. While these techniques are animated to depict elemental influences, in practice, they do not actually invoke those elements. This discrepancy frustrates some fans, who seem to overlook that Demon Slayer belongs to the Shonen category. The exaggerated visual representation serves to amplify the experience, making it a hallmark of Shonen art style that attracts viewers.

Disclaimer: This article represents the author’s personal opinion and may contain spoilers.

Understanding the Critique of Breathing Techniques in Demon Slayer

And Why It Lacks Substance

Giyu Tomioka using his water breathing style (Image via Shueisha)
Giyu Tomioka executing his water breathing style (Image via Shueisha)

The breathing styles integral to Demon Slayer are vital for the members of the Demon Slayer Corps, as they amplify strength and facilitate the defeat of demons, showcasing the series’ narrative diversity.

Upon their introduction, many fans mistook these breathing styles for elemental powers, particularly when watching Giyu Tomioka in action. Observing the visual effects led them to believe that he utilized actual water to combat demons, which is a misinterpretation.

In truth, breathing styles do not create physical elements; they simply echo the characteristics of their namesake. Whether deploying Water or Fire techniques, there is no real element at play. While the stunning visuals suggest a deeper magic, the underlying simplicity can lead to disappointment among devoted fans.

Long-range attacks in the series are a result of shockwaves (Image via Shueisha)
Long-range attacks depicted as shockwaves (Image via Shueisha)

Fans yearn for humanity to display extraordinary power. However, they often fail to appreciate that humanity’s essence lies in its vulnerability. Demon Slayer celebrates the frailty of human existence—not as a weakness, but as the source of true strength. The narrative posits that mortality can be leveraged as a competitive edge in the fight against demons.

This lavish visual style is a traditional element within Shonen anime, akin to works such as Blue Lock and Ao Ashi, which portray intense moments through vibrant imagery.

Concluding Insights

The root of fan discontentment regarding the breathing styles in Demon Slayer often stems from heightened expectations of what constitutes fantasy and magical abilities. As an action-adventure narrative focusing on combat, audiences look forward to a complex power hierarchy. When coupled with the demons’ magical prowess, many fans seek an equilibrium between both forces.

    Source & Images

    © 2021 The Filibuster Blog