On March 23, 2025, the third episode of American Idol season 23 premiered on ABC, featuring a noteworthy audition from the aspiring singer John Foster. Initially, judge Luke Bryan harbored reservations about Foster’s potential to progress in the competition—but a remarkable second performance transformed Bryan’s assessment dramatically.
“That last song certainly showed us that. I’m a Yes. I went from no to yes.”
At just 18 years old, Foster, who hails from Addis, Louisiana, made a memorable entrance to the audition room, bringing with him a taste of Cajun culture and a burning ambition to become a “singing oncologist.”Currently pursuing a degree in biology, he also has aspirations of attending medical school. Foster’s audition featured two country songs that sparked lively discussions among the judging panel regarding his vocal skills.
Luke Bryan’s Evolving Opinion on John Foster’s Talent
Initial Reactions to Foster’s First Performance
Foster kicked off his audition with a rendition of Don’t Rock the Jukebox by Alan Jackson. While his country style was evident, judge Carrie Underwood quickly encouraged him to select a different song to better showcase his vocal range.
“Alan Jackson was my first concert in 1994. I was 11. I love me some Alan. Do you perhaps have another song that kind of showcases your vocals a little more?”Underwood suggested.
Meanwhile, Lionel Richie expressed his wish to uncover a deeper side of Foster’s artistry:
“I want to hear more of who you are, and I mean, I love the timber. You’re going to carve your way out now and start making your sound.”
Delivering a Captivating Duet
In response to Underwood’s feedback, Foster transitioned to performing Goodbye Time by Conway Twitty. Accompanied by his acoustic guitar, Foster’s rendition was so impressive that Bryan jumped in to sing along. Following the performance, Underwood praised his ability to connect emotionally with the song:
“I got the information that I wanted out of that. There’s such a sweet spot in your voice that that song really brought out.”
She advised him to remain authentic as he continued in the competition and to consider how to navigate different genres in future performances.
Despite his initial skepticism regarding Foster’s vocal talent, Bryan did a complete 180 after witnessing the strength of the second performance. He articulated his transformation:
“I want to see you try to make that sound work. You have a nice voice and a lot of great tools.”
The Golden Ticket to Hollywood
Subsequently, all three judges rendered their votes in favor of sending Foster through to Hollywood. Upon receiving his coveted golden ticket, Foster shared his insights about the audition journey and the influence of Underwood’s suggestions:
“I never expected to be doing a duet with Luke Bryan today…I definitely have Carrie to thank for my audition being a success. That second song really drove it home,”he reflected to host Ryan Seacrest.
Foster emphasized the importance of adaptability in the competition, noting that his willingness to adjust his song selection was instrumental in earning his place in Hollywood.
Tune in to American Idol season 23, airing Sundays at 8 PM ET on ABC, to follow the unfolding journey of contestants like John Foster.