Grand Theft Auto: Vice City has secured a cherished spot in the hearts of gamers, particularly among those who adore the Grand Theft Auto franchise. However, this classic title is not without its shortcomings. Serving as the second entry in the 3D Universe of the series, Vice City presents several issues that some observers deem significant. Fans frequently overlook these flaws, contributing to the perception that the game may be overrated.
This article delves into five compelling reasons that argue why gameplay in GTA Vice City might not live up to its iconic reputation.
Top 5 Reasons Why GTA Vice City Is Overrated
1) Expansive Yet Underwhelming Map

Despite offering a larger map than its predecessor, Grand Theft Auto 3, GTA Vice City is burdened by an abundance of empty space. Much of the game’s open world features sandy beaches that serve little purpose other than aesthetic value. The limitations of the old game engine restrict meaningful exploration and engagement in these areas, rendering the world less vibrant than it appears on the surface.
2) Absence of Checkpoints
The gameplay experience in GTA Vice City is notably marred by the absence of checkpoints during missions. This design choice can be frustrating, especially during lengthy and challenging missions. Players who fail at any point—especially toward the end—must restart from the very beginning, hindering the flow and enjoyment of the game. Furthermore, Rockstar’s insistence on requiring players to return to mission locations to restart exacerbates this problem.
3) Unsatisfactory Driving Mechanics
Driving in GTA Vice City leaves much to be desired, as the mechanics frequently feel clunky and disjointed. Maneuvering vehicles around corners leads to a jarring experience, where cars abruptly shift from one trajectory to another. This choppiness is compounded by the fragility of vehicles, which tend to take damage easily, making it challenging for players to cherish their favorite rides for an extended period.
4) Limitations of the Protagonist
While Thomas “Tommy”Vercetti is revered as a standout character within the Grand Theft Auto lore, he comes equipped with surprising limitations. Notably, he cannot swim or exit moving vehicles, which feels restrictively archaic for a protagonist in an open-world environment. Additionally, his health diminishes rapidly, adding to the frustrations players may experience during gameplay.
5) Hostile Law Enforcement

The wanted level system in Vice City is notoriously aggressive, allowing law enforcement to quickly catch up to players. Evading police becomes a daunting task, as the wanted stars remain active for an extended period, even when an individual seeks refuge in hidden spots. Additionally, the game escalates the threat level to six stars, introducing SWAT and other formidable police units, which can deter newer players from fully enjoying the experience.