The Rise and Fall of Universal’s Dark Universe: An In-Depth Analysis
Following the tremendous success of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), many movie studios have endeavored to create their own interconnected cinematic franchises. However, the majority have struggled to reach the same heights as Marvel Studios. Notably, Warner Bros. scrapped its DCEU in favor of a reboot, Fox’s X-Men series concluded after Disney’s acquisition, and Sony is still grappling with achieving a successful Spider-Man Universe. Amid this turmoil, one cinematic universe was envisioned with great potential: Universal’s Dark Universe.
Officially launched with the 2017 film The Mummy, starring Tom Cruise, the Dark Universe aimed to resurrect Universal’s iconic monsters in a shared narrative. This ambitious venture was reminiscent of the studio’s prior success with crossover films that predated the MCU. Unfortunately, the reboot of The Mummy fell short both critically and at the box office, leading to the premature cancellation of the Dark Universe before it could truly begin.
Understanding the Dark Universe’s Demise
Initial Setbacks: The Mummy’s Underperformance
The Mummy ignited Universal’s Dark Universe but failed to establish a sustainable foundation for future films. With a dismal 15% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and a mere 35% audience score, it was clear that the film did not resonate with critics or viewers. Financially, the film grossed about $80 million domestically and just shy of $410 million globally, a performance that, considering its nearly $200 million budget, was insufficient to break even.
Building a cinematic universe on such shaky ground proved challenging, and The Mummy did not provide the necessary momentum for the Dark Universe’s expansion. While it may have been possible for the universe to recover after just one release, Universal’s decision to halt production before deeper investments were made was likely a prudent financial choice. Despite this setback, many ambitious projects had been planned for the Dark Universe.
Revitalizing Classic Characters: The Van Helsing Film
A Star-Studded Cast with Channing Tatum
In July 2017, it was announced that a new film centered on Van Helsing was in development, with Channing Tatum set to star. This reboot aimed to reinvent the 2004 film featuring Hugh Jackman, which itself had met with disappointment at the box office. Thus, a new take on Van Helsing faced a challenging road ahead, even with a high-profile actor like Tatum involved.
Although the project was never officially canceled, the dissolution of the Dark Universe plans effectively shelved the Van Helsing reboot. However, a new iteration is reportedly in the works, separate from the Dark Universe. Unfortunately, Tatum’s involvement appears unlikely in this new direction.
Potential Project: Dracula Untold 2
Could Have Expanded the Universe
While The Mummy was branded as the launching film of the Dark Universe, the 2014 installment Dracula Untold is often viewed as its unofficial predecessor. Initially conceived as a standalone film, its production was adapted to fit into the shared universe concept following the announcement of Universal’s cinematic ambitions. However, no sequel ever materialized, marking another setback for Universal’s attempts to revive its classic monsters.
Much like The Mummy, Dracula Untold underperformed both critically and financially, further complicating any efforts to establish a franchise.
Exploring Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde’s Role
The Anticipated Role of Russell Crowe
Russell Crowe was cast to embody Dr. Jekyll/Mr. Hyde within the Dark Universe, envisioning his character as a counterpart to Marvel’s Nick Fury—serving as the nexus connecting various segments of the franchise. He made a brief appearance in The Mummy, which followed the MCU’s template of character crossovers.
Despite this promising setup, the cancellation of the Dark Universe curtailed any plans for a standalone film featuring Crowe’s character, although there were no formal developments confirmed for such a project.
Standalone Success: The Invisible Man
Johnny Depp’s Involvement
In February 2016, Johnny Depp was attached to a reboot of The Invisible Man, a pivotal character within Universal’s monster roster. His involvement initially raised expectations for the project, as Universal secured two major stars in Depp and Cruise. However, after the Dark Universe faltered, Depp exited the project, allowing for a fresh direction under director Leigh Whannell, leading to the successful 2020 release starring Elisabeth Moss.
The Invisible Man achieved critical acclaim and box office success, demonstrating that the allure of these classic monsters could thrive outside of a shared universe.
The Wolf Man: Uncertain Future
Dwayne Johnson’s Interest
While The Wolf Man was never formally in development, reports indicated that Dwayne “The Rock”Johnson was in talks to star. Universal aimed to attract prominent Hollywood talent in a bid to rejuvenate its cinematic universe. However, after the lackluster performance of Black Adam, discussions regarding Johnson’s potential involvement ceased.
With the collapse of plans for The Wolf Man, Universal has pivoted towards revitalizing its monster legacy independently, with an upcoming standalone film scheduled for January 17, 2025, featuring Christopher Abbott in the leading role.
The Creature from the Black Lagoon: A Lost Opportunity
Speculation Around Scarlett Johansson
Discussions surrounding a reboot of The Creature from the Black Lagoon emerged around the time of The Mummy. Reports suggested that Scarlett Johansson was slated to star in the titular role, indicating an intent to align with contemporary cinematic trends. However, these plans ultimately amounted to nothing.
The Bride of Frankenstein: A Promising Concept
Angelina Jolie’s Potential Role
A reboot of The Bride of Frankenstein was announced with plans for Bill Condon to direct. With Angelina Jolie perceived as a potential lead, expectations were high, especially given the legacy of the original film regarded as a classic. Despite this potential, the project failed to advance to production, leading to speculation on whether Jolie would ever portray the character.
Frankenstein: The Legendary Monster’s Uncertain Future
Javier Bardem’s Connection
Though no official film centered on Frankenstein emerged within the Dark Universe framework, Javier Bardem was pegged to play Frankenstein’s monster in the planned The Bride of Frankenstein. Bardem’s involvement was highlighted in a promotional cast photo alongside other major stars, signaling his integral role in this cinematic vision.
Despite lingering interest from Bardem in the character, current projects have shifted as directors such as Guillermo del Toro are now developing their interpretations. A Frankenstein reboot is on the horizon with rising star Jacob Elordi expected in a leading role.
The Future of the Dark Universe
Rethinking the Framework
Despite its rocky start, Universal has not abandoned the idea of revitalizing its legendary monsters. By shifting focus away from the interconnected universe concept, films like The Invisible Man, along with other standalone projects, have begun to gain traction and recognition.
Interestingly, the Dark Universe branding will continue to live on through themed areas at the upcoming Universal Epic Universe, set to open on May 22, 2025, showcasing the studio’s commitment to their enduring legacy. Although the cinematic attempt at the Dark Universe might be concluded, fans can still anticipate exciting developments featuring their favorite classic movie monsters.