After the recent breakup between 90 Day: The Last Resort star Josh Weinstein and Natalie Mordovtseva, speculation has arisen regarding Josh’s new romantic interest. Widely recognized as Natalie’s boyfriend within the reality TV franchise, their separation unfolds as they both navigate the intricacies of post-relationship dynamics. Natalie, who came to the U.S. on a K-1 visa from Ukraine to marry Mike Youngquist, ultimately found herself unhappy in that union and sought something different, leading her to Josh, the CEO of a modeling agency in California, in hopes of launching her modeling career.
However, their relationship was fraught with complications. Natalie expressed dissatisfaction with the way Josh treated her, frequently lamenting that he never invited her to his home in Arizona. Additionally, she often found herself financially dependent on him. As her desire for a family grew, and recognizing that Josh did not share her aspirations, she reached out to Mike, hoping to rekindle their relationship. Ultimately, after approximately three years of a tumultuous partnership highlighted by conflicts and miscommunications, Josh and Natalie concluded their journey on the second season of The Last Resort.
Insights on Josh’s New Relationship After Natalie
Josh Shares Surprising Confessions Regarding His Dating Journey
In February 2025, Josh was candid during an appearance on “The Sarah Fraser Show” podcast, confirming the status of his relationship with Natalie. He articulated that despite their tumultuous experiences, they maintained a friendship, expressing that he cared for her deeply. He acknowledged Natalie’s reliance on him, feeling a sense of responsibility to be her support system during difficult times, which contributed to extending their relationship beyond its end date.
During this interview, Josh hinted at a new romantic prospect. While he did not disclose her identity, he noted that he was dating someone from the wider 90 Day Fiancé universe. This revelation has stirred intrigue among the franchise’s fans, leading to various theories regarding his new companion. Speculations have linked him to recently single participants such as Vanja Grbic and Kara Rojer, but Jenn Potthast has emerged as a frequently mentioned possibility.
Speculation Surrounding Josh and Jenn Potthast
Exploring the Rumors: Josh and Jenn’s Connection
For avid followers of 90 Day Fiancé, Jenn is recognized as Elizabeth Potthast’s sister. Reports surfaced in February 2023 showing Josh and Jenn together at a restaurant, seemingly during one of the periodic breaks in his and Natalie’s on-again, off-again relationship. The captured moment, where Josh shared a drink with Jenn, sparked dating rumors that Jenn has further fueled through her social media presence.
Moreover, an Instagram Q&A featured Jenn responding to whether she’d ever been approached for a show related to the franchise. Her cryptic response, while playful, hinted that she might indeed have a new romantic interest, possibly aligning with Josh. Given their prior acquaintance before his debut on 90 Day Fiancé, speculation around their connection is palpable.
Public Sightings of Josh and His New Girlfriend
Recent Sightings: First Public Appearances with a New Girlfriend
In March 2025, **Shabooty** shared photos of Josh at the Las Vegas airport, reportedly on his way to Phoenix. Accompanied by an unidentified woman, speculations about her identity as his new girlfriend began to circulate. Details such as his first-class travel ticket and the presence of a small dog added layers to this emerging narrative. However, her identity remained a mystery as her face was not captured in any of the images.
“Yep, it’s his new girlfriend!”
Sarah Fraser, host of the aforementioned podcast, contributed to the intrigue by confirming that the woman photographed was indeed Josh’s new partner. She indicated that audiences could expect her introduction during the upcoming Tell All episodes of 90 Day: The Last Resort, promising an engaging twist as fans further explore this budding romance.
Speculation on Josh’s Mystery Girlfriend
Theorizing the Identity of Josh’s New Connection
Recent updates have aligned with claims made by Sarah, particularly following a teaser for the forthcoming Tell All episode where host Shawn Robinson inquired about any new relationships brewing for Josh. His affirmative response suggested that he had developed strong feelings for this new individual, which piqued Natalie’s visible discontent. Shawn mentioned that they had invited the new woman, leaving viewers guessing.
“Some of you might recognize her already,” she stated, creating a buzz among the cast.
While many speculate it could be Jenn, I suspect that Josh may be romantically involved with someone from the production crew of 90 Day: The Last Resort. If Shawn’s comments hint at prior familiarity, it could indicate a deeper connection formed behind the scenes, fostering intrigue as this narrative unfolds.
90 Day: The Last Resort airs every Monday at 9 p.m. EDT on TLC, where viewers can tune in for more developments.
Sources: The Sarah Fraser Show, therealitytvmess/Instagram, 90dayfiance_alexa/Instagram, Shabooty/Instagram, 90 Day Fiancé/Instagram