Character Flaws: The Incompetent Movie Heroes We Can’t Rely On

Movie characters are often valued for their imperfections, which add depth and complexity to their narratives. Nonetheless, some characters embody a level of incompetence that disqualifies them from being seen as true heroes. Not all cinematic stories revolve around high-stakes scenarios where characters must bear the weight of the world; in fact, many portray characters who falter under much less pressure. These inept protagonists often evoke a sense of relief, as witnessing their attempts to ‘save the day’ would likely lead to more disaster than success.

The depiction of characters whose obsessions lead to their downfall is prevalent in films. Such portrayals reveal not only flaws but also the potential for empathy, as audiences sometimes relate to characters struggling against their own failings and the expectations of those around them. While some of these flawed characters alienate viewers with their harmful actions, others manage to invoke sympathy through their relatable shortcomings.

8
Holland March – The Nice Guys (2016)

Portrayed by Ryan Gosling

In The Nice Guys, Ryan Gosling shines as Holland March, possibly the least effective private investigator to hit the big screen. Set against the backdrop of 1970s Los Angeles, the film encompasses humor, style, and action as Holland partners with the more competent Jackson Healy (Russell Crowe). By flipping traditional crime thriller tropes on their heads, Holland is depicted as a clumsy father who, despite his earnest efforts, often fails to get things right.

While Holland’s charm endears him to the audience, his blunders considerably hinder the progress of their investigation. Ultimately, Holland’s charisma does not translate into competence, as he struggles to effectively execute his plans. Over time, The Nice Guys has developed a cult following, celebrated for the comedic chemistry between Gosling and Crowe.

7
Aldo Raine – Inglourious Basterds (2009)

Played by Brad Pitt

Quentin Tarantino consistently reveals the flaws of his characters, as exemplified by Aldo Raine in Inglourious Basterds. As various narrative threads converge, viewers witness Aldo and his team inadvertently step beyond their familiar violent antics into a new realm of challenges. While the film is marked by graphic violence and gore, a sense of loss permeates as Aldo’s comrades fall during the mission, highlighting his limitations as a protector.

Aldo does manage to secure a moment of triumph by the film’s conclusion, yet his victory comes through the lens of revisionist history and improbable plot developments. In a more realistic context, Aldo would hardly be the person you’d trust with strategic planning or leadership, which adds an intriguing layer to his character.

6
Gale Hawthorne – The Hunger Games (2012)

Portrayed by Liam Hemsworth

In the backdrop of dystopian narratives like The Hunger Games, love triangles often serve as pivotal story elements. Gale, Katniss (Jennifer Lawrence), and Peeta (Josh Hutcherson) find themselves caught in a complex web of allegiances and identities. Despite Gale’s formidable presence as Katniss’s past, his behavior reveals a disturbing self-interest when she returns from the Games.

Gale’s character reveals troubling ideological compromises as he navigates rebellion, prioritizing his selfish interests over the moral consequences of his decisions. Although Katniss struggles with her own complexities, she embodies a clearer sense of moral clarity, positioning her as a true hero in contrast to Gale’s failures.

5
Jeffrey Beaumont – Blue Velvet (1986)

Portrayed by Kyle MacLachlan

David Lynch’s Blue Velvet epitomizes the exploration of dark human nature, with Jeffrey as a key figure amidst this unsettling narrative. Jeffrey yearns to escape his picture-perfect suburban life by delving into the mysterious and dangerous world inhabited by the woman he loves. Regrettably, his endeavors stem more from a naive fantasy than genuine investigative skill.

As events unfold, it becomes evident that Jeffrey is not the astute detective he imagines himself to be; he is simply an inexperienced youth drawn into a perilous mystery. By the conclusion, he comprehends the gravity of his precarious choices, coming face to face with the consequences of his reckless pursuits.

4
Walter Sobchak – The Big Lebowski (1998)

Portrayed by John Goodman

John Goodman delivers a memorable performance as Walter Sobchak in The Big Lebowski, serving as a foil to Jeff Bridges’ laid-back character, the Dude. As they encounter a case of mistaken identity, Walter’s interventions often complicate matters rather than alleviate them. Walter’s misguided attempts to intervene exacerbate their troubles, primarily due to his inflated sense of intellect.

The convoluted storyline of The Big Lebowski thrives on Walter’s blunders, adding a comedic layer to the otherwise chaotic narrative. If Walter had been paired with anyone but the Dude, his incompetence would likely have led to dire consequences much earlier in the story.

3
Dale Denton & Saul Silver – Pineapple Express (2008)

Played by Seth Rogen & James Franco

In Pineapple Express, James Franco and Seth Rogen form an uproarious duo that exemplifies a new wave of stoner comedies. Caught in a web of criminal conspiracy, Dale and Saul navigate a series of misadventures fraught with peril—yet they often emerge from their escapades relatively unscathed due to sheer luck. Throughout their journey, the duo’s extreme blunders bolster the hilarity of their narrative, even as the audience recognizes their improbable continued survival.

Their dynamic and humorous chemistry keep viewers engaged, but the plot absurdities compound the realization that had the stakes been any higher, they would not fare well as heroes in a more serious scenario.

2
Mickey Barnes – Mickey 17 (2025)

Portrayed by Robert Pattinson

Bong Joon Ho’s sci-fi dark comedy, Mickey 17, is replete with characters that flaunt incompetence, including the titular Mickey. Despite being thrust into perilous situations, Mickey possesses a distinctive knack for finding the most ridiculous ways to meet his end. As the narrative unfolds, it becomes clear that he is neither the strategic hero nor the brains of the operation; instead, his girlfriend, Nasha (Naomi Ackie), proves to be far more capable.

While Mickey’s comedic missteps drive the story forward, his lack of foresight—exemplified by his fateful decision to sign up as an Expendable—is a testament to his unpreparedness for the trials ahead. Ultimately, Mickey’s survival is contingent on the support he receives from others, highlighting his unsuitability for heroic roles.

1
Bella Swan – Twilight (2008)

Portrayed by Kristen Stewart

Kristen Stewart faces a unique challenge in portraying Bella Swan in the Twilight series, as Bella’s character often falls short of traditional heroic qualities. Her tendency to create chaos and place herself in peril renders her a perplexing figure, particularly evident when her mere presence invites danger to those around her, including the enigmatic Edward (Robert Pattinson).

Even after her transformation into a vampire, Bella’s journey is marred by her reliance on others for protection, frequently leading to turmoil and even tragic consequences. While her character ultimately undergoes development, notably once she becomes independent, it remains evident that her backstory is riddled with moments of failure to act heroically on her own accord.

For more insights, you can check the original source here.