Carrie Underwood has revitalized American Idol with her remarkable presence, drawing attention to the show in ways it hasn’t experienced in recent years. As a celebrated contestant turned judge, Carrie’s return symbolizes a significant moment for both the show’s legacy and her own career. Winning the iconic talent competition in 2005 positioned her perfectly for a comeback two decades later.
Her star power elevates the show’s profile well above that of her co-judges, Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie. Carrie’s journey from a hopeful contestant to a household name has allowed her to connect uniquely with audiences. Fans see her as someone who embodies the dreams of aspiring artists, making her an indispensable figure in the current season. Although some critiques focus on her judging style, several compelling reasons support her continued role on the show.
6 Carrie Has A Huge Fanbase
Carrie Is A Major Country Music Star
Among the most recognizable American Idol alumni, Carrie joins the ranks of other successful stars like Kelly Clarkson and Jennifer Hudson. In the realm of country music, she reigns supreme.
With over 85 million record sales globally and eight Grammy Awards to her name, Carrie’s achievements speak volumes. Her brand of music resonates across diverse age groups, establishing a fan base that outstrips even that of American Idol. Despite controversies, including her performance at President Donald Trump’s inauguration, Carrie’s connection with fans remains strong, particularly among those feeling marginalized by mainstream music.
5 Carrie Has Empathy For The Contestants
Carrie’s Been In Their Shoes
One reason Carrie excels as a judge is her ability to relate to contestants. Having auditioned and triumphed on American Idol at just 21, she serves as a tangible example of how the show can propel singers to stardom. This shared experience fosters a nurturing environment for participants.
Though some may perceive her approach as overly gentle, it is her relatability that shines through. Contestants may feel the weight of performing before a star like Carrie, yet her warm demeanor offers comfort. An example of this occurred when she engaged with Breanna Nix during early auditions; Carrie’s supportive words to Breanna and her young son emphasized the importance of motherhood, showcasing her genuine empathy.
4 American Idol Has Made Carrie More Relevant
Carrie Is Being Exposed To A Whole New Fanbase
Following her rise to fame post-American Idol, Carrie became a country superstar. However, her ongoing role as a judge exposes her to a broader audience beyond her established country fan base, ensuring her relevancy in popular culture.
While American Idol may not be the cultural powerhouse it once was, being invited back to judge is a notable accolade. For viewers unfamiliar with Carrie’s music, her consistent presence on the show reinforces her status as a major figure in the industry.
3 Carrie’s Career Is Inspiring To Contestants
Carrie Is One Of American Idol’s Success Stories
During her time on American Idol, Carrie has been chronicling her journey in a video diary titled “Idol to Icon.”This initiative not only illuminates her travel from a hopeful contestant to an acclaimed performer but also serves as an inspiration to current contestants, emphasizing what the show can offer.
Carrie’s triumphant story signifies that potential stardom is attainable through the right mix of talent and timing, though it’s recognized that not every victor will reach similar heights.
2 Carrie Gives Thoughtful Critiques
Carrie Chooses Her Words Carefully
Unlike some judges who take a harsher approach, Carrie’s empathetic nature informs her critiques. While some may believe that her kindness undermines her authority, it is a hallmark of her unique judging style. She offers feedback that is not only sincere but also uplifting.
For instance, she praised finalist Gabby Samone, stating that her “voice was made for a song like that.”Her affirmations encourage contestants and motivate them to strive for excellence in their performances.
1 Carrie’s Performances Are Awe-Inspiring
Carrie’s Performances Are A Reminder Of Her Talent
Throughout the season, judges have opportunities to perform; Carrie is no exception. Her renditions of “Alone”and “How Great Thou Art”captivated audiences, but her performance of the latter was exceptionally poignant, reflecting her faith and personal beliefs.
When Carrie takes the stage, it not only showcases her exceptional talent but also reinforces her well-deserved status in the music industry—mercifully reminding aspiring contestants that with unwavering dedication and skill, they too may find success.
Catch American Idol airing Sundays and Mondays at 8 p.m. EDT on ABC.
Sources: Carrie Underwood/Instagram