Although HBO’s Game of Thrones opted to omit Catelyn Stark from its storyline, her significance is far from diminished in George R.R. Martin’s forthcoming novel, The Winds of Winter. This eagerly awaited volume remains in progress, with vast narratives from the previous five A Song of Ice and Fire installments to explore. By reflecting on past events, projected character developments, and anticipated outcomes, we can delve into the potential trajectory of Lady Stoneheart’s arc.
For those familiar with the television series, it’s important to remember that Catelyn Stark met her demise during the infamous Red Wedding depicted in A Storm of Swords, the series’ third book. Following her death, we learn that her body was pulled from the river by Nymeria, Arya’s direwolf, and later discovered by the Brotherhood Without Banners. Here, Beric Dondarrion sacrificed his own life to resurrect Catelyn, transforming her into Lady Stoneheart.
5
Lady Stoneheart Spares Jaime Lannister
This Isn’t Where Jaime’s Story Ends
In her quest for vengeance, Lady Stoneheart roams the Riverlands, executing members associated with House Frey or House Lannister as retribution for her family’s slaughter at the Red Wedding. By the end of A Dance with Dragons, Brienne of Tarth manages to lure Jaime to confront Lady Stoneheart after receiving a choice between killing him or facing her own hanging. Given the final words Robb Stark heard — “Jaime Lannister sends his regards”— it’s likely that mercy will be scarce for the Kingslayer.
Dubbed “Mother Merciless,”Lady Stoneheart is unlikely to let Jaime escape unscathed. Numerous theories suggest potential ways Jaime could evade death in the early chapters of The Winds of Winter, as many believe this is not the closure intended for his character. Furthermore, Jaime has experienced prophetic visions about participating in the critical Battle for the Dawn, leading to speculation that he must ultimately fulfill the Valonqar prophecy by killing Cersei.
4
Lady Stoneheart Leads The Red Wedding 2.0
The Freys & Lannisters Have It Coming
The theory of a “Red Wedding 2.0″posits that the Starks will exact direct revenge on the Freys similarly to the original saga. While Arya assassinates Walder Frey in Season 6, the novels might present a different narrative where Catelyn is at the forefront of vengeance. A potential wedding between a Frey and a Lannister would create a prime opportunity for her revenge, especially considering that characters like Daven Lannister have become prime targets for Lady Stoneheart’s wrath.
3
Lady Stoneheart Sacrifices Herself For One Of Her Daughters
Her Last Efforts In Life Were To Protect Sansa & Arya
Catelyn Stark’s primary aim was always to safeguard her family. In a desperate act, she surrendered Jaime as a means to potentially rescue Sansa and Arya, yet she died before achieving any reunification. Although it may be premature to conclude Lady Stoneheart’s saga in The Winds of Winter, a fitting end could see her sacrificing everything one last time to save her daughters. Her ultimate act of defiance could be to gift her life for Sansa or Arya, affirming her enduring maternal instinct.
2
Arya Will Give Lady Stoneheart The Gift Of Mercy
Lady Stoneheart Isn’t Meant To Be Alive
The moment Arya encounters her mother, transformed into Lady Stoneheart, will be heartbreaking yet pivotal for her character development. Despite Thoros of Myr’s reservations about her state, Arya’s encounter with Catelyn likely will provoke horror at what she has become. It may be that Arya must ultimately grant her mother a swift release, encapsulating the bittersweet nature of growth and maturity.
1
Lady Stoneheart Will Proclaim Jon Snow As King In The North
Catelyn Knows About Robb’s Will
In life, Catelyn Stark had a deep-seated animosity toward Jon Snow, even opposing Robb Stark’s decision to designate Jon as his heir to the North. Yet a crucial plot point in A Song of Ice and Fire that the television adaptation glossed over is Robb’s secret will, known only to a select few, including Lady Stoneheart. There’s strong speculation that Robb intended to name Jon as his successor, an indication of his plans before his tragic demise.
While the notion that Lady Stoneheart could resurrect Jon seems more speculative, her knowledge surrounding Robb’s will could still play a substantial role in elevating Jon’s standing. Unlike the show, which reveals Jon’s heritage through various means, the books might create a narrative whereby Howland Reed discloses this vital information to Lady Stoneheart, influencing her actions before her potential demise.