5 Anime Characters Who Surpassed Their Mentors and 5 Who Couldn’t

In the realm of anime storytelling, one recurring theme is the evolution of characters who surpass their mentors. These narratives often derive from deep-seated mentor-student relationships that serve as critical catalysts for character growth. Typically, the story arc revolves around a gifted disciple guided by a seasoned mentor, eventually achieving their own mastery through perseverance, diligence, and tenacity.

Such intergenerational mentorship not only illuminates personal growth but also highlights that not every student is destined for success. Despite fervent efforts and passion, some remain eclipsed by their mentors due to factors like missed opportunities or innate differences in talent. However, those anime characters who do surpass their mentors embody the realization of potential and the breaking of limitations.

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author.

Top 5 Anime Characters Who Surpassed Their Mentors

1) Naruto Uzumaki – Naruto

Naruto Uzumaki
Naruto Uzumaki (Image via Studio Pierrot)

Naruto Uzumaki’s journey illustrates the classic tale of a character surpassing their mentor. Starting off as the least promising student at the Ninja Academy, Naruto receives invaluable guidance from legendary ninjas like Kakashi Hatake and Jiraiya. His relentless dedication allows him to master the Rasenshuriken, ultimately achieving the prestigious title of Seventh Hokage, surpassing all previous leaders in power.

Armed with techniques such as Sage Mode and the powers of the Nine-Tails chakra, complemented by his Six Paths abilities, Naruto not only conquers his foes but also transforms them into allies, culminating in his recognition as the strongest shinobi to have ever lived.

2) Edward Elric – Fullmetal Alchemist

Edward Elric
Edward Elric (Image via Studio Bones)

Edward Elric epitomizes the character arc of surpassing mentors through sheer resilience and innovative thinking. Learning alchemy from Izumi Curtis, he ironically transcends her teachings after a profound failure drives him to develop the ability to perform alchemy without the traditional circles, a feat Izumi never achieved.

His journey leads him to confront fundamental truths about alchemy, culminating in the ultimate sacrifice of his own abilities to save his brother. This act underscores that Edward’s true growth—strength, wisdom, and emotional maturity—far surpasses that of his mentor.

3) Izuku Midoriya – My Hero Academia

Izuku Midoriya
Izuku Midoriya (Image via Bones)

Initially born without a Quirk, Izuku Midoriya inherits the legendary power One For All from All Might, the greatest hero. While All Might relies solely on brute strength, Midoriya innovates by unlocking additional abilities from past users, granting him unprecedented versatility and growth.

As Midoriya masters One For All, he naturally rises above All Might, positioning himself as a candidate for the role of the greatest hero ever, thereby embodying the essence of anime characters who surpass their mentors.

4) Gohan – Dragon Ball Z/Super

Gohan
Gohan (Image via Toei Animation)

Gohan’s transformation from a timid child to a formidable fighter makes him a noteworthy mention. Trained by both Piccolo and Goku, he realizes his potential during the Cell Games, particularly when he unlocks Super Saiyan 2. Despite inconsistencies in his dedication, he reinforces his capability in Dragon Ball Super’s Tournament of Power, tapping into his “Ultimate”form.

Through his determined efforts, Gohan demonstrates that he can indeed surpass the fighting expertise of his legendary mentors, affirming his role as a character who has surpassed the limits set before him.

5) Ichigo Kurosaki – Bleach

Ichigo Kurosaki
Ichigo Kurosaki (Image via Studio Pierrot)

Ichigo Kurosaki’s remarkable growth trajectory positions him among the anime characters who have soared beyond their mentors. Rapidly becoming powerful enough to contend with his trainers—Kisuke Urahara, Yoruichi, and the Vizards—Ichigo leans on his genetically unique blend of Shinigami, Quincy, and Hollow powers to gain an edge.

His mastery of his true Zanpakutō and the ability to balance his diverse bloodlines allow him to surpass even the Captain-Commander ranks, defeating foes that none of his mentors could. This achievement marks him as a definitive example of growth beyond his original teachers.

5 Anime Characters Who Could Not Surpass Their Mentors

1) Kyojuro Rengoku – Demon Slayer

Kyojuro Rengoku
Kyojuro Rengoku (Image via Ufotable)

Kyojuro Rengoku, despite his dedication and potential as a Flame Hashira, tragically falls short of surpassing his father, Shinjuro. In his quest for mastery, Kyojuro ultimately meets his end before fully realizing his capabilities, revealing the inherent limitations that can accompany mentorship.

Throughout the series, it becomes evident that Shinjuro’s advanced knowledge of Sun Breathing techniques lingers as an unachievable benchmark for Kyojuro. His valiant stand against Akaza only emphasizes the unfulfilled gap between his achievements and his father’s peak prowess.

2) Genos – One Punch Man

Genos
Genos (Image via Madhouse)

The dynamic between Genos and Saitama underscores the stark realities of mentor-student relationships, with Genos’s technological upgrades contrasting sharply against Saitama’s raw, unmatched strength. Despite Genos’s growth and enhancements, he remains perpetually overshadowed by Saitama’s effortless power.

Genos’s latest forms, like Blue Dragon mode, showcase his abilities, yet his reliance on cybernetic augmentations inhibits him from truly grasping his full potential compared to Saitama’s inherent gifts.

3) Gray Fullbuster – Fairy Tail

Gray Fullbuster
Gray Fullbuster (Image via J.C.Staff.)

Gray Fullbuster’s development as an ice wizard is commendable, yet he has yet to surpass his mentor, Ur. Her legendary control over ice magic, epitomized by her ultimate sacrifice in sealing away Deliora, remains unattainable. Gray’s use of Ice Devil Slayer Magic simply cannot compete with Ur’s versatility and intrinsic creativity.

Ur’s mastery of complex spells that persist beyond her death underscores a level of power and emotional maturity that Gray has not yet reached, even as he continues to grow.

4) Yuichiro Hyakuya – Seraph of the End

Yuichiro Hyakuya
Yuichiro Hyakuya (Image via Wit Studio)

Yuichiro Hyakuya embodies untapped potential, yet he remains beneath his mentors due to deficiencies in emotional control and tactical acumen. Lacking the discipline exhibited by warriors like Lieutenant Colonel Guren Ichinose, Yuichiro’s raw strength is undermined by his erratic choices.

His volatile bond with the Seraph of the End acts as a double-edged sword, presenting obstacles that hinder his growth and prevent him from attaining his mentors’ strategic skills and teamwork expertise.

5) Konohamaru Sarutobi – Boruto

Konohamaru Sarutobi
Konohamaru Sarutobi (Image via Studio Pierrot)

Konohamaru Sarutobi, despite being the grandson of the legendary Third Hokage, struggles to rise to the heights of his renowned mentor, Naruto. Although he showcases proficiency in various skills, he fails to emulate the legendary status and feats accomplished by Naruto and his predecessors.

In the context of the Boruto series, Konohamaru finds himself often outmatched by opponents that his predecessors could effortlessly overcome, emphasizing his struggle to break free from their shadows despite his training and pedigree.

Conclusion

The exploration of anime characters who surpass their mentors serves as a poignant narrative that reflects the boundless potential of human endeavor. These stories validate the idea that through a blend of determination, talent, and a sincere commitment to learning, students can achieve remarkable successes that honor their teachers’ foundations.

Conversely, those who do not manage to surpass their mentors highlight the enduring barriers shaped by talent and circumstance, demonstrating that relentless determination might not always suffice against the realities of one’s limits.

By juxtaposing these compelling narratives, we gain insightful perspectives on character development and the intricate dynamics of mentorship, cementing the master-student relationship as an essential pillar of anime storytelling.

    Source & Images

    © 2021 The Filibuster Blog