Warning: This article contains SPOILERS for 1923 Season 2, Episode 6.
The character Zane Davis (Brian Geraghty) astonished viewers with his rapid recovery from brain surgery in Season 2 of 1923. After suffering a brutal beating in the first season finale and undergoing a gruesome surgery to address a brain bleed, Zane’s swift return to action raised eyebrows among fans and fellow characters alike. Remarkably, he was seen walking and talking mere minutes post-operation, defying expectations regarding such a serious medical procedure.
By the conclusion of Season 2, Episode 6, Zane was not only back on his feet but also fulfilling his duties at the Yellowstone ranch, effectively preparing for imminent challenges. This unexpected healing, though a notable plot point, has been pointed out humorously by the show’s writers. In a clever nod to this implausibility, the series included a moment of levity regarding Zane’s extraordinary recovery, a rare lighthearted instance amidst the show’s often dark narrative.
Humor in Recovery: Zane’s Journey
The Duttons Question Zane’s Remarkable Recovery
The writers of 1923 clearly understood that Zane’s quick rebound was outside the bounds of realism. During a pivotal moment in Episode 6, Zane nonchalantly quipped that “a week’s long enough to heal anything,”leading to Jacob Dutton (Harrison Ford) offering a witty retort: “I can’t think of one thing that can heal in a week.”This exchange showcases both self-awareness and humor, particularly as Zane expressed eagerness to go horseback riding despite having an open skull wound.
Contrasting Recoveries: Jacob Dutton’s Timeline
Jacob Dutton’s Grueling Recovery Versus Zane’s Quick Comeback
While Zane’s astonishing recovery is noteworthy, it’s particularly striking when contrasted with previous injuries depicted in the series. In Season 1, Jacob Dutton faced multiple gunshot wounds inflicted by Banner Creighton (Jerome Flynn) and his cohorts. Notably older and in a more dire situation than Zane, Jacob required extensive time to recuperate, with a timeline spanning months before he could engage with his surroundings once again.
This dramatic difference in recovery time raises questions not only about Zane’s storyline but also about the pacing of Season 2 overall. With a prolonged narrative arc surrounding Spencer’s (Brandon Sklenar) quest to reach Montana, other plot developments, including Zane’s recovery, seem hastily condensed. If the show had allotted sufficient time for Zane’s healing process, it likely would have mirrored Jacob’s more plausible recovery narrative.
|
1923 Season 2 Release Schedule |
||
|---|---|---|
|
Episode # |
Title |
Release Date |
|
1 |
The Killing Season |
February 22 |
|
2 |
The Rapist Is Winter |
March 2 |
|
3 |
Wrap Thee In Terror |
March 9 |
|
4 |
Journey the Rivers of Iron |
March 16 |
|
5 |
Only Gunshots to Guide Us |
March 23 |
|
6 |
The Mountain Teeth of Monsters |
March 30 |
|
7 |
A Dream and a Memory |
April 6 |
The distinction between Zane’s rapid recovery and Jacob’s prolonged one brings to light potential issues regarding the pacing of 1923 Season 2. The storyline’s hurried progression might have contributed to Zane’s near-miraculous healing, leading viewers to question the overall consistency of the series. A more realistic approach to Zane’s recovery would have enhanced the narrative’s credibility and fused seamlessly with the existing storytelling framework.