In a dramatic shift within the X-Men narrative, Charles Xavier has removed himself from the planet altogether. This pivotal moment coincides with the revival of his wife, Lilandra Neramani, who brings alarming news of their daughter Xandra being in peril. As a result, the franchise has formally sidelined Professor X, allowing him to prioritize his family’s needs while engaging with Jonathan Hickman’s Imperial saga, marking Marvel’s next significant cosmic conflict.
Xavier’s departure seems fortuitous, given that his standing within the team has waned in recent years. A series of narrative arcs have depicted him in a less-than-favorable light, leading to team morale being undermined by his leadership. Ultimately, differing opinions regarding Professor X have splintered the team, but with him absent, it presents an opportunity for a new leader to step in and restore harmony within the ranks.
1 Cyclops
The Military Leader of the X-Men
Scott Summers, renowned as Cyclops, once epitomized Charles Xavier’s vision for mutantkind, mastering the ideals instilled by his mentor. Positioned as a premier strategist, Cyclops has often been likened to Captain America in his tactical acumen. However, the dynamics have shifted significantly; he now finds himself disillusioned with Xavier’s leadership, which ironically places him in an advantageous position as a leader of the X-Men.
Having witnessed the failures of his mentor firsthand, Cyclops is uniquely equipped to avoid repeating those missteps. Understanding the signs of potential self-destruction that plagued Xavier, he can navigate a new course for the X-Men that diverges from his predecessor’s mistakes.
2 Magneto
A Historical Figure in Heroism and Villainy
Magneto, a complex character who has oscillated between ally and adversary of the X-Men, has been integral to their story since its inception. Despite his tumultuous past, he has dedicated recent years to elevating the status of mutants alongside the team, becoming a prominent figure on Krakoa. With a nuanced transformation underway, Magneto stands poised to embrace a leadership role reminiscent of Professor X.
This potential shift offers a rich thematic irony; after decades of opposing Xavier’s ideals, Magneto’s evolution into a leader could herald a new era for the X-Men, allowing him to craft a vision for mutants that reflects the lessons learned from his complicated relationship with Xavier.
3 Storm
A Leadership Force of Nature
Ororo Munroe, better known as Storm, is a veritable powerhouse within the X-Men universe. Her journey from a formidable mutant to a respected leader has solidified her significance beyond mere combat. Critics may argue that she has surpassed the necessity for the X-Men, yet the fact remains that the team truly benefits from Storm’s presence. As an Omega-level mutant and former leader, her invaluable experience equips her to guide the X-Men through turbulent times.
Her storied history includes leading the team during the ’90s and serving as headmaster of their academy, thereby demonstrating her extensive leadership experience. With the X-Men in disarray, Storm’s commanding presence is essential for restoring stability and unity.
4 Jean Grey
The Pinnacle of Power
As one of the original members of the X-Men, Jean Grey has evolved into a figure of unmatched power within the team. Through her many transformations, she has merged the essence of every mutant into her being, making her an embodiment of mutantkind’s potential. Given the current environment of anti-mutant sentiment in the Marvel Universe, having a leader of her caliber is critical. Jean’s leadership would not only bolster their ranks but also carry a symbolic weight, representing the unity of all mutants.
Much like Xavier once symbolized hope for mutantkind, Jean Grey’s potential leadership embodies a collective vision for the future, solidifying her as an option for the X-Men’s new leader.
5 Dani Moonstar
A New Generation Leader
Dani Moonstar, a veteran of the New Mutants, is an ideal candidate for future leadership within the X-Men. Her extensive dedication to mentoring emerging mutants makes her a prime contender for heading Xavier’s school. Marvel’s hints suggest that Dani’s ascension to leadership is imminent, culminating in a character evolution that honors her legacy in the franchise spanning over four decades.
Having previously co-led the New Mutants, Dani’s transition to leading the X-Men feels like a natural progression, further solidifying her place in the ongoing saga.
6 Kitty Pryde
An Emerging Leadership Figure
Kitty Pryde is acutely aware of Charles Xavier’s shortcomings, having experienced the consequences of his decisions firsthand. With each leadership opportunity she embraces, she remains mindful of avoiding the same pitfalls. Her credibility continues to grow as she consistently showcases her leadership capabilities, ascending the ranks of the X-Men with determination and resolve.
In recent storylines, Kitty has captained the Marauders, contributed to the Quiet Council during the Krakoa period, and is now focused on nurturing the next generation in the Exceptional X-Men. These evolving roles position her for potential advancement to a full X-Men leadership role.
7 Rogue
The Surprise Choice for Leadership
Rogue’s journey has been remarkable, evolving from a member of the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants to one of the X-Men’s most formidable allies. She continues to shatter expectations, particularly with her recent appointment as leader of one of the X-Men’s divisions. As the Uncanny team diverges from Cyclops’ faction, Rogue exhibits leadership qualities that resonate deeply within the current dynamics, especially as she retains an element of admiration for Charles Xavier.
This balanced perspective allows her to appreciate both the strengths and flaws of Xavier’s leadership, providing a foundation for her own approach as a potential leader.
8 Dazzler
An Unexpected Leader with Unique Potential
Dazzler may often be categorized as a pop star within the Marvel universe, but her capabilities extend far beyond her musical talents. In fact, Dazzler serves as a symbolic bridge between mutants and humanity. Acknowledged in a potential future where she rises to become the President of the United States, her acceptance as a prominent figure reflects her popularity and trusted status among both mutants and humans alike.
In the story arc depicted in All-New X-Men #17, she is portrayed as “the most recognizable, most liked, most trusted mutant of the last 20 years,”evidenced by the enthusiastic following she garners at her performances. This optimistic trajectory raises a pertinent question: if Dazzler can gain the trust to lead a nation, why not the X-Men?
9 Emma Frost
A Controversial Yet Effective Leader
Emma Frost epitomizes the dichotomy of heroism and villainy within the X-Men lore. As the White Queen of the Hellfire Club, her past is enshrouded in complexity; however, her ability to lead is unequivocal. Not only does she embrace leadership roles with confidence, but she also possesses the innate talent to elevate those around her while instilling a belief in mutantkind’s potential.
Emma combines Xavier’s most admirable traits with her unique approach to leadership, making her an ideal contender for the next chapter in the X-Men saga.
10 Nightcrawler
A Beloved X-Man Ready for Leadership
Typically seen in a supporting capacity, Nightcrawler has exhibited the qualities of a leader, especially during the Krakoa era where he participated in the Quiet Council and founded the Legionaries. His unwavering optimism and faith in a better future resonate with the ideals once championed by Charles Xavier.
While Xavier’s formidable charisma inspired many, Nightcrawler embodies a similar dreamer’s spirit that encourages unity and trust among mutants. Should he take on formal leadership, he could become a figure that transcends Xavier’s legacy, fostering hope and solidarity within the X-Men.