My Hero Academia stands out as one of the most beloved anime series, yet numerous fans have voiced their opinions on areas for improvement within this shonen masterpiece. It is not uncommon for die-hard followers of any franchise to critique certain elements of the narrative, and My Hero Academia is no exception. A recent discussion on a Reddit thread by u/the8thchild highlighted various fan theories and suggestions.
Despite their deep affection for the show, enthusiasts have shared numerous hot takes. These range from advocating for the inclusion of specific characters to proposing that certain character deaths should have remained permanent. While these suggestions may be controversial, some may indeed enhance the overall quality of the series.
10 Deku Should Have Retained His Quirk
Deku Should Not Have Lost His Quirk in the Final Chapters
Among the most shocking developments in My Hero Academia occurs at the concluding chapters when Deku’s One For All Quirk disappears permanently. While some fans embraced this trajectory, believing it allowed Deku to pursue his dream of becoming an inspirational teacher, others felt conflicted. They argue that retaining his Quirk would have preserved All Might’s legacy and complemented Deku’s hero journey.
9 Bakugo’s Character Growth Surpasses Endeavor’s
Endeavor’s Redemption Arc Was Significant, but Bakugo’s Growth Was More Profound
Within the series, many characters experience profound development. Endeavor’s transformation from a flawed father into a more compassionate figure stands out as a pivotal storyline. While his growth elicits respect, it does not match the transformation of Bakugo—once an antagonist, he evolves into a hero willing to sacrifice everything for Deku’s safety. Bakugo’s journey of redemption resonates deeply as he learns humility and empathy.
8 The Series Needed More Slice-of-Life Scenes
My Hero Academia shines during moments that delve into the everyday lives of U.A. High School students, providing comic relief and relatability. Scenes such as the Christmas party or school concerts dart in and out of the narrative, but the overall balance between action-packed arcs and lighter moments could benefit from further development. More slice-of-life segments would enrich the story’s emotional tapestry, allowing viewers to connect more intimately with the characters.
7 Class 1-B Deserves More Spotlight
Class 1-B Is More Than Just Rivals of Class 1-A
My Hero Academia features two main classes: Class 1-A and its counterpart, Class 1-B. Despite both classes being part of the Hero Course, Class 1-B often plays a secondary role, primarily serving as rivals. Characters like Neito Monoma and Tetsutetsu Tetsutetsu showcase unique abilities and personalities that deserve more exploration. Class 1-B should have received additional development to elevate their significance beyond mere adversaries to Class 1-A.
6 My Hero Academia Has Numerous Overlooked Characters
Many Characters Don’t Receive Adequate Developments
With a sprawling cast, it is inevitable that not every character receives the spotlight they deserve. Many fan-favorites like Midnight or the villain Mr. Compress remain underdeveloped, leaving viewers yearning for deeper narratives around these characters. The tendency of My Hero Academia to favor certain arcs causes many character journeys to go unexplored, diminishing the richness of the overall narrative.
5 Bakugo’s Resurrection Was Unnecessary
Bakugo’s Death Would Have Strengthened the Narrative
The moment Bakugo sacrificed himself to protect Deku was one of the series’ most poignant scenes. While his subsequent revival brought relief to many fans, it also diminished the emotional weight of his act. By allowing Bakugo to remain deceased, the stakes of the story would have escalated, presenting a darker and more intense atmosphere, and truly solidifying his sacrifice’s significance.
4 Endeavor Did Not Earn His Redemption Arc
The Severity of Endeavor’s Past Should Not Be Overlooked
Endeavor’s journey toward redemption is met with divided opinions among fans. While his dedication to change is commendable, many argue that the horrific treatment he inflicted on his family cannot be so easily forgiven. This contentious aspect of his character arc raises questions about the morality of redemption in a narrative heavily focused on heroism and justice.
3 Systemic Issues in Hero Society Need Greater Attention
The Exploration of Hero Society’s Flaws Is Insufficient
Throughout My Hero Academia, various flaws in the hero society are hinted at, revealing a much darker reality behind the facade of heroism. Characters like Toga and Spinner embody the marginalized who turn to villainy due to societal neglect. The critique of hero figures focused on fame rather than altruism, as seen with the Hero Killer Stain, deserves more extensive discourse to deepen the series’ impact.
2 My Hero Academia Could Benefit from a Longer Format
The Series Omits the Students’ Final Year
At a glance, My Hero Academia appears lengthy with seven seasons, but it covers only the first two years of the students’ high school experience. The omission of their final year and a rushed epilogue eight years later leaves many loose ends untied. Extending the narrative by a few more chapters could allow for richer closures and enhance the emotional stakes.
1 All For One Is a Mediocre Villain
All For One’s Lack of Depth Weakens His Role
As the primary antagonist of My Hero Academia, All For One is often criticized for being one-dimensional. His characterization lacks the complexity that many viewers desire, as he embodies evil without a discernible motive. Although a villain with unexplored depths can offer intrigue, All For One’s portrayal falls flat, failing to resonate with the audience on a meaningful level.
Source: u/the8thchild on Reddit