Baldur’s Gate 3 made a remarkable debut in 2023, captivating players with its intricate narratives and richly developed characters. Nevertheless, it is important to acknowledge that no game achieves perfection. As much as I appreciate BG3, there are specific aspects that other RPGs have executed more successfully. These aspects include more dynamic player character development, broader decision-making options, and a more responsive world that reacts to player choices.
This observation does not diminish the greatness of Baldur’s Gate 3, which is filled with intricate lore, compelling companions, and impactful choices that matter. The RPG genre is vast and diverse, enriched by a history of exceptional games, some of which have left indelible marks in particular facets. Whether you’re exploring a fantasy realm or venturing into space, here are some standout RPGs that have carved out their own identities.
10 Dragon Age: The Veilguard Offers Exceptional Character Customization
Released By BioWare In 2024
While Dragon Age: The Veilguard has received mixed feedback from segment of fans regarding its storyline, the character creation tool is widely praised. Although Baldur’s Gate 3 provides an admirable selection of hair, eye colors, and skin tones, it limits character customization with only a few presets for each race.
The Veilguard, in contrast, offers extensive options for character creation. Players designing their character, Rook, have the freedom to use presets or craft a unique appearance through various sliders and tools. This abundance of options significantly enhances personalization, making each character stand out.
9 Fallout 4 Excels in Weapon & Armor Modifications
Released By Bethesda In 2015
While Baldur’s Gate 3 features an extensive array of weapons and armor for players to discover, the gear remains static and cannot be modified. On the other hand, Fallout 4 allows players to enjoy a higher level of customization through its modification system.
Using workbenches, players can enhance their weapons and armor, adjusting elements for better performance. Modifications range from altering gun barrels for improved accuracy to enhancing armor with features like ballistic weave for extra protection. This system allows players to tailor their equipment to fit specific playstyles and character builds.
8 Knights of the Old Republic Offers One of the Most Compelling Character Backstories
Released By BioWare In 2003
Baldur’s Gate 3 allows players to select either a custom character or one of the seven Origins, each with excellent backstories. However, achieving a balance between a compelling narrative for player characters and allowing personal player expression is challenging. The Dark Urge comes close, but few examples match the nuance of Revan from Knights of the Old Republic.
Similar to the Dark Urge, players in KOTOR begin without memory, creating a blank canvas. The game delivers a shocking twist when Darth Malak reveals Revan’s identity, crafting a depth-filled history while still allowing player-driven development and choices.
7 Morrowind Exemplifies the Depth of the Elder Scrolls Universe
Released By Bethesda In 2002
Baldur’s Gate 3, set within the expansive lore of the Forgotten Realms, succeeds in engaging both new and returning players. However, Morrowind, the third entry in the Elder Scrolls series, takes immersion to the next level with its intricate world-building on the island of Vvardenfell.
Morrowind intricately weaves an extensive lore narrative with the political dynamics of the Dunmer people, crafting a richly complex landscape. As the Nerevarine arrives, the engagement between the Empire and Great Houses intensifies, leading the player on an epic journey marked by prophecies and divine intervention.
6 Skyrim Provides Unparalleled Character Flexibility
Released By Bethesda In 2011
Transitioning from one Elder Scrolls title to another, Skyrim introduces a remarkable degree of character customization. Unlike Baldur’s Gate 3’s defined D&D classes, Skyrim allows players to learn from a vast range of 18 skills, facilitating an array of viable build configurations.
The brilliance lies in Skyrim’s flexibility; players can improve any skill at any point, enabling character builds to evolve with challenges faced. While BG3 allows for respec options, Skyrim’s development mechanic melds seamlessly with its open-world exploration.
5 Mass Effect 3’s Narrative Embodies Epic Scope
Released By BioWare In 2012
Baldur’s Gate 3 tells a thrilling story focused on a small party striving to defend Faerûn from evil. Nevertheless, for a grand narrative that encompasses the fate of an entire galaxy, Mass Effect 3 stands out.
This concluding chapter of the beloved trilogy interlinks various plotlines against the backdrop of a spectacular final battle for the Milky Way. Despite the polarizing reaction to its ending, the scale and ambition of ME3’s story remains unparalleled in the RPG genre.
4 Fable’s Narrative Responsiveness to Player Choices
Released By Lionhead Studios In 2004
Baldur’s Gate 3 features numerous morally ambiguous choices throughout its gameplay, yet NPC responses often remain static, regardless of players’ actions. However, in Fable, every evil action resonates within the game’s world.
The series effectively employs a fundamental morality system that tracks player choices, shaping both the hero’s alignment and the general player experience. As your character navigates quests, visible changes occur, enhancing the weight of decisions made and making the experience more fulfilling and dynamic.
3 Mass Effect 2 Features Exceptional Companions
Released By BioWare In 2010
Companions play a significant role in enhancing the RPG experience, often aiding in storytelling and player engagement. Baldur’s Gate 3 excels in this area with its memorable companions. Yet, Mass Effect 2’s roster of allies is also noteworthy.
Building on its predecessor’s success, ME2 introduces richly developed characters, each with unique backgrounds and skills that enrich gameplay. Their personal narratives intertwine with the overall mission, making them stand out and ensuring players remain invested throughout the journey.
2 The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt’s Abundance of Story Choices
Released By CD Projekt Red In 2015
One of the standout features of Baldur’s Gate 3 is the multitude of variables considered in quest designs, leading to diverse outcomes. However, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt perfects this concept with choices that significantly alter storylines far into the future.
Despite dedicating countless hours to the game, I have yet to uncover every possible result. Geralt’s decisions, both minor and major, reverberate throughout the game, enhancing the significance of each choice and ensuring a meaningful living world.
1 Dragon Age: Origins Features a Memorable Villain
Released By BioWare In 2009
A compelling villain is a cornerstone of any great RPG, motivating heroes to rise against evil. While Baldur’s Gate 3 presents formidable adversaries with grand ambitions, Dragon Age: Origins showcases a more personal, intricate antagonist in Loghain Mac Tir.
Loghain’s depth stems from his flawed yet relatable motivations; he is a soldier driven by the desire to protect his homeland, manipulated into making tragic mistakes. This dimension makes Loghain a fascinating villain, as the best antagonists are often those with whom players can resonate.